Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Do you think?

who's talking here?

~*MarLa Singer*~ 1
Noel 7
Little Miss Knowitall 5
Jacky 4
☼♥Brandi♥ 2
Muse 8
Emmy 2
DaisyMae 1
Jenn. 5
IED 1
Crystal 1
♥JaCkLyNn♥ 10
Amapeli 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Do you think?

A child who is about to be 11 is old enough to give input on whether or not he needs ADHD medication?

Yes Vote
 
 40.7% (11)
No Vote
 
 33.3% (9)
Maybe Vote
 
 25.9% (7)
Muse --- 17 years ago -

A child who is about to be 11 is old enough to give input on whether or not he needs ADHD medication?  

Noel --- 17 years ago -

After being on it for the decade between 6 and 16, I'm biased as can be against ADHD medications. I'm STILL a messed up individual because of what that crap did to me. The strength and intensity of those drugs are, to me, way too much for the system of someone who's still developing. At least, they were in my case. So if he's saying, "NOPE, don't want that," then I'd say, yyyeah, he's old enough to have input. At the end of the day - your child, your choice! 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 17 years ago -

Serious? Is he stabilized on his meds or does he still have issues? Is it ADHD/hyperactive or something else? My 14 yr old is ADHD/inattentive/impulsive. We tried him for 10 days without meds during the summer... Needless to say, he took his meds before going to school today. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 17 years ago -

Noel, Meds are greatly different than what they were, even 2-3 years ago... 

Noel --- 17 years ago -

Be that as it may, that's what they thought when I was on them, too. I distinctly remember a doctor saying, "These medications have come a long way." I trust a mother's instinct with her own kids. But I'm also living proof of the fact that you absolutely can NOT know what's going to happen to your kids because of those drugs until they're completely grown up and finished developing, unless you've got a crystal ball handy! 

DaisyMae --- 17 years ago -

I think that sometimes these medications are over prescribed.. It really is not an "easy fix" to behavior problems.. IF you as a parent feel there is an issue then maybe you should look into medications, but I don't see how an 11 year old would honestly be able to weight the options as well as is required. 

Jenn. --- 17 years ago -

i vote no meds at all. period. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

Serious I'm dead serious. My son was on Concerta from the time he was 4 (because I was told that I HAD to put him on it and being young and him my only child at the time, I did what they told me to do) until this past June (he's 10). We took him off of it by mistake- the dr had forgotten to sign the script and we were unable to get it filled on that Friday. Saturday was a TERROR. Sunday almost as bad. Come Monday- he was fine. Right now, he's a little more reckless and doesn't make the RIGHT decisions sometimes but he doesn't appear to be needing the medicine (to me). Well since he came off of it we have caught him cursing, stealing and now trying to smoke. He is asking to go back on it. He said it's calmer when he's on it. He doesn't need to always be doing something. *I* think that the medicine SCREWS up a kid and that his bad choices are just that- bad choices. 

Crystal --- 17 years ago -

I think the child should be allowed to give imput, but should not be allowed to decide (if that makes any sense).. I'm speaking in a general sense though, I have no personal experience on the topic (my childern are 4 and 7 months) 

♥JaCkLyNn♥ --- 17 years ago -

i wish my parents had completely listened to me when i was that age and telling them what was wrong with me....instead of always calling me a hypochondriac and drama queen. to this day im a hypo drama queen with countless medical issues...ugh 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

don't see how an 11 year old would honestly be able to weight the options as well as is required. He was on them for 6 years. He's been off of them for 3 months. I believe at 10, he knows the effect of the meds on his body. 

Noel --- 17 years ago -

*I* think that the medicine SCREWS up a kid and that his bad choices are just that- bad choices. I completely agree with you. I think those doctors did your son a horrible injustice, and that if you'd been able to raise him WITHOUT meds, by now, you might not've even had to go through what Saturday must've been like for you. When I turned 16, I got sick of the horrible effects those drugs were having on me, as well as the secondary drugs they ended up sticking me on to counteract the INITIAL side effects, and sick as well of parents and doctors thinking I was "too young" when I told them that they made me feel awful and were effecting me negatively, so I started flushing them down the toilet. It makes me sick to my stomach to think of other kids having to go through some of the same crap I did with the different rounds of meds they had me on for my ADHD. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

Noel, that Saturday I cried like I had never cried before. He was manic. He was screaming. Like a drug addiction. I would never want to see him like that again. It's not the ADHD. It's the MEDICINE. 

♥JaCkLyNn♥ --- 17 years ago -

yeah my daughter who is the same age, can tell when she forgets her singulair, so yeah, they can tell...and i believe he should have some choice, and kudos to him for feeling comfortable enough to voice it to you, and kudos to you for raising him in an environment in which he feels comfortable enough to feel like he can make his choices known to you. 

Noel --- 17 years ago -

It's not the ADHD. It's the MEDICINE. EXACTLY. If my mother had looked into it more, meh. . . I would be so much better off today. I remember reading on a support group about the long-term side effects of these drugs, and being able to finally go, ". . . Omg. This is where it comes from. Finally, an answer." There should never have BEEN a question. I should not have been a SIX YEAR OLD ON SPEED against my will. 

♥JaCkLyNn♥ --- 17 years ago -

damn can i get some speed please, i promise it wont be against my will...sorry just trying to lighten the mood. but really...id love some speed, these kids are wearing me down today BAD! 

Noel --- 17 years ago -

sorry just trying to lighten the mood. This is probably the most personal I've ever gotten on CPU, because it leaves a bad taste in my mouth to bring anything personal to a public forum, but I feel so strongly about it that I was like. . . completely incapable of stopping my fingers. Sorry if I'm bringing anyone down. :P 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 17 years ago -

Does he go to any kind of therapy? We did counseling before resorting to the meds. He's only been on meds since January - and it HAS made a world of difference. I tell you though, based on what your son said, he just may need something, not necessarily the Concerta. The cursing, smoking etc can be attributed to the age. Is he starting puberty? Mine started puberty at almost 11. He had a HUGE growth spurt and hair started growing EVERYWHERE. He's been shaving since just before his 12th birthday. If he doesn't shave every day, he has a full beard in a day and a half. 

♥JaCkLyNn♥ --- 17 years ago -

not bringing anyone down noel, giving very good input...imo 

IED --- 17 years ago -

Usually discipline works better than medicine for behavior modification. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

Usually discipline works better than medicine for behavior modification. Obviously. It wasn't a matter of behavior modification- I've never used medicine for that. Jac- I had the dr put me on Adderall- it gives me energy and keeps me from being slow. It also helps me focus alot better. PLus it has the added bonus of weight loss. Deb, he doesn't go to counseling. They never offered it. Like I said, he was my first and only child at the time and I still believed everything the doctors said. 

Noel --- 17 years ago -

Usually discipline works better than medicine for behavior modification. I agree. Maybe not with the word "discipline," but with certain methods of teaching/reacting to your kids when they have ADHD, and some of them take more than a few weeks to start being effective. Therapy might be a way to go, but also, check around your local bookstore! LOADS of helpful resources! My husband has ADD - not quite the same thing, but within the realm of comparison - and his mother never medicated him, ever. She put him on a strict and certain diet, for starters, but avoided pills entirely. The two of us side-by-side are incomparable when it comes to being well-adjusted and healthy adults. He IS one! 

♥JaCkLyNn♥ --- 17 years ago -

M can u just tell a doc to give u that for real? does it cause headaches? 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

It doesn't give me headaches. It does give me dry mouth like crazy but I LIKE that because it makes me drink TONS of water. I went to the psychologist and asked him for it. I told him I was ADD. I am- I forget where my keys are like 95% of the time. I don't finish cleaning one room before I'm on to another. I reread pages several times because I can't concentrate. It works well for me and I lost like 35 lbs on it in like 2 months. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

I want to leave him off because when he's on it, he's so serious. He doesn't ever get silly. I know it sounds stupid but once he was off of it, now he dances and sings and hugs me ALL the time. He's a kid again. It's like I gave him his childhood back when I took him off of it. 

Noel --- 17 years ago -

It's like I gave him his childhood back when I took him off of it. Yeah, that was definitely something I hated about it. It was so unsettling, I could -feel- my personality shutting down. I think it's part of the reason I became a creative writer - I was robbed of any other outlet to be fanciful or expressive. And it's not like I wouldn't TRY, I just couldn't do it, it was like there was a wall I couldn't push past, if that makes sense. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 17 years ago -

I think it depends on the child. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 17 years ago -

MN, I would have him re-evaluated... 

Jenn. --- 17 years ago -

It's like I gave him his childhood back when I took him off of it. and that is what he is. a child. it just amazes me how right now in this life - if anything is seemingly wrong or different about a child - meds are one of the first things thrown at them. unbelievable. 

Jenn. --- 17 years ago -

they told us that our daughter needed to be put on blah blah blah steroid cream MULTIPLE TIMES DAILY for her eczema. pffffffffft. ONCE IN A BLUE MOON FOR US. at the rate they want us to use the medicine - we should be up for refills every other day or so. we are still using the first tube she has ever had. it's been 2 years. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground