Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Opinions

who's talking here?

SugarCanesOldProfile 1
~*MarLa Singer*~ 1
Chelle 1
Shnookums 1
Jacky 3
Muse 11
champatlife 3
Truthbetold 2
Dusk2Dawn 1
Jewel 3
DaisyMae 2
Lovebug 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Opinions

So, here is the story. My 11 year old was playing at the park. There was a bike there that had been there a few days and my son took it for a joy ride around the neighborhood with one of his friends. Well anyway, last night when we came home from dinner, the bike was in the house. My husband took the bike (along with a few other bikes that were broken from our garage) and put them on the curb. Well anyway, the bikes were gone this morning. Now, the dad comes banging on my door wanting me to pay $200 for the bike. He said the bike was a Christmas gift. Now, I DO feel the need to do something bc my son WAS in the wrong for taking it in the first place. HOWEVER, his son left it at a community park for DAYS. Now, if you were in this position, would you pay for it? Also, he did call the cops and file a report but in his report, he told the cops it was taken from his front yard which is a lie- he stood in my front yard and told me in front of witnesses that it was left at the park. So what would you do? And why?

Yes, pay for it Vote
 
 36.8% (7)
No, do not Vote
 
 63.2% (12)
maybe Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Muse --- 16 years ago -

So, here is the story. My 11 year old was playing at the park. There was a bike there that had been there a few days and my son took it for a joy ride around the neighborhood with one of his friends. Well anyway, last night when we came home from dinner, the bike was in the house. My husband took the bike (along with a few other bikes that were broken from our garage) and put them on the curb. Well anyway, the bikes were gone this morning. Now, the dad comes banging on my door wanting me to pay $200 for the bike. He said the bike was a Christmas gift. Now, I DO feel the need to do something bc my son WAS in the wrong for taking it in the first place. HOWEVER, his son left it at a community park for DAYS. Now, if you were in this position, would you pay for it? Also, he did call the cops and file a report but in his report, he told the cops it was taken from his front yard which is a lie- he stood in my front yard and told me in front of witnesses that it was left at the park. So what would you do? And why? 

Jacky --- 16 years ago -

Your husband should have sent the bike back to the park... not the curb. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

And I agree. I didn't know that until after the fact and the bikes were already gone. My son is clearly at fault but so is the owner. I am willing to pay half of the cost BUT he told me that it was bought at Toys R Us for $200 at Christmas. Well it's 8 months old now and Toys R Us has it for $105 (but the original price was still only $130) 

Shnookums --- 16 years ago -

oh i'd pay him half and call it a day, since SOME fault is on your son!!! BAD parenting on his part for allowing his son to leave it in the park for days then switch the story in THEIR favor. whats that teaching his son? blah! 

DaisyMae --- 16 years ago -

I voted pay for it. However, I mean you SON should pay for it. I do think that both your son and the other boy have lessons to learn. Now my child is much younger, so I may be off, but at 11 years old you son should know better than to take something that is not his. But then again the other boy should not have left if there so long.

Also I would tell the father that you will consider paying 100 (or what ever you feel is fair. A child's bike that is 8 months old an clearly been in the elements for while (the time it was at the park) is not worth the full original purchase price.

I personally would make my child "pay" for it by confiscating allowance till it reached the amount that you had to pay or earn in by doing extra chores around the house.

OH I also agree with Jacky, Why did you husband just put it at the curb?

** I am clearly too slow :) 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Because no one KNEW where it came from- my son lied and told us he got it from beside the dumpster.

My son does know better. There is absolutely no excuse. NONE. I have taught him better.

I seriously think that since it's $105 NEW, I should only have to pay for half of it since it was irresponsible on BOTH of our parts. 

Jacky --- 16 years ago -

Pay half and call it a day. That's reasonable to me - send $50 over there and call it a day. And of course your son should have to pay for it. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

My son is losing his allowance already because of it. He will pay for it. I have no idea what possessed him to take something that wasn't his and then LIE to me about it. I don't like it at all. Even if I only have to pay half of it, he's still going to forfeit his allowance for quite some time. 

DaisyMae --- 16 years ago -

I agree MN when I posted my reply only Jacky had replied. I think you have a good handle on the situation. Is the other parent reasonable at all? 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

No, I apologized and he hollered at me that "sorry" wasn't enough. Well, I KNOW that but that doesn't mean I shouldn't still be courteous and say it. I told him we would make reparations. What more can Ido? I'm not paying $200 for a bike that wasn't brand new, was misused by HIS son and is BRAND NEW $105 today. 

SugarCanesOldProfile --- 16 years ago -

yeah i'd give him 25% to half of the BRAND NEW price. 

Truthbetold --- 16 years ago -

I'd pay for it... 

champatlife --- 16 years ago -

eh... hard to tell. Since your son lied and now the father is lying. So it makes you wonder where the bike really was and for how long. And how would anyone know it had been there for 3 days, etc? and not just a day?

I wouldn't give them $200 since the bike is now $105- so that would be the tops I would give them... but if you believe the boy was at blame too then only you can decide the proper amount. I mean if your son didn't "steal" it then chances are someone else would have... which is no real excuse. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

my husband said he isnt paying for it at all bc the playground is a public area and because they were negligent. I'm going to talk to J though. we are responsible ffor at least half and I'm going to offer the guy 50 and if he doesnt take it then oh well 

champatlife --- 16 years ago -

it's deff one of those situations where you can say "tough cookies" to the other kids' parent, and I wouldn't think negatively about that choice, but then you think "if the situation was flipped what would you want done?"

ETA: but because everything is so wishy washy and I think it's hard to know the REAL story it would make me think about giving them some money for it. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 16 years ago -

Who abandons their bike in a park? The kid should have to go without a bike just for being that irresponsible and stupid to do such a thing. Granted, your child does know better than to take something that does not belong to him, but it was there for days! Any kid would have wanted to take some seemingly abandoned bike for a ride. 

Lovebug --- 16 years ago -

I would not pay for it. Maybe throw them $50 but thats about it.

A) The bike was missing for days before anyone did anything.
B) Its not worth $200
C) That child clearly isnt responsible enough to own an expensive bike.

If I were the other kids parent my son would spend the rest of the summer without a bike to learn some responsibility. 

Truthbetold --- 16 years ago -

Hmmm. Once again my thoughts aren't the same. I think this whole story sounds crazy. If this is what your son told you I'd believe him. I would ask to either a replace it by actually buying the bike or some proof of cost. Bikes for adults are usually less than 150.00. I don't know why your hubs threw it out especially if he knew he didn't buy it or it worked but to each his own. I would if this was me make my Hub and som
figure it out since between their actions it can't be returned. But I'm a total B_itch today so please forgive if I come off bad! I hope you all get to end this soon! 

Dusk2Dawn --- 16 years ago -

Your husband should have sent the bike back to the park... not the curb.

It's was in your possesion, that may leave you on the hook. 

Jacky --- 16 years ago -

Your husband should have sent the bike back to the park... not the curb.

It's was in your possession, that may leave you on the hook.



Yeah, I agree with this. I myself, would definitely send at least half over there.


Meanwhile, how did we figure out that the bike was there for 3 days prior? 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

Meanwhile, how did we figure out that the bike was there for 3 days prior? 

That was what I was wondering..

Your son lied, the other parent lied, and there is no way of knowing the full truth.

I definitely would NOT pay 200 bucks for something that now costs 105 brand new. I'd agree with half. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

first of all, a neighbor who lives next to the park confirmed to the cop that the bike had been there for at least 3 days. second, when the bike was set on the curb, we thought it had come from the dumpster and since he KNEW they were coming to take the dumpster away. he didnt want the bike to get trashed. 

champatlife --- 16 years ago -

MN, I'd just do whatever you and your family feels is right. I wouldn't think any less of you or you hubby telling the parent to "shove off" you guys have to use your own moral compass in a situation like this. :) 

Jewel --- 16 years ago -

No need to get feisty MN!

Just trying to understand everything. LOL 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

by law we are not liable. I'm still going to pay half bc I feel its right. 

Chelle --- 16 years ago -

Regardless of how long the bike was at the park, you should pay for at least a portion of it because your son wrongfully took something that wasn't his and now it's gone for good as a result of that.

Someone stole my daughter's scooter out of our garage and we honestly looked for it for about two weeks. Then we happened to go to a park a few blocks from our house and there was her scooter laying on the ground. Someone must have taken it and then just thrown it on the ground and left it there later on. So I would have been pissed if someone else had come along and taken it again. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Julie. I was just getting irritated bc I already said that my husband didnt know where it came from. he OBVIOUSLY would have taken it back to the park if he knew that it came from there. the guy came today and efused the half we offered, then told us he was going to the command about it (typical). anyway. someone took the bike from our yard and then dumped it sometime today behind the youth center. we returned it so we're good. 

Lovebug --- 16 years ago -

The dad sounds like an a$$. He should be angry at his child for being irresponsible- not at you guys. I think its very reasonable for you to offer half. If the kid left it at the park for 3 days he clearly didnt take good care of it- so Im sure it wasnt in "new" condition. So if he refused half then hes clearly a jerk. 

Lovebug --- 16 years ago -

P.S. MN I missed you!!!! 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

I missed you too!!!! I'm glad its over 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground