Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

American Girl introduces homeless doll

who's talking here?

SugarCanesOldProfile 1
Nik.Nik♥™ 1
Shnookums 1
Vicky 2
Emmy 2
LelaBelle 8
007 9
LadyE 1
IED 2
mommy of 2 boys♥ 4
*Lauren* 1
WooTang 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

WooTang (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

Now im feeling a little conflicted on the idea of this new doll. I understand where the company may be coming from in respect to using the doll as a tool to open kids up to all aspects of life, especially with homelessness becoming more of a reality to some with the economy the way it is. What happened to kids just being kids. Dolls were just that, dolls. Kids used their imagination and the dolls we whatever they wanted them to be. I dont feel that kids should be burdened with this. They grow up to fast as it is, let them be little as long as possible. I know that if I had gotten a homeless doll when I was younger, with the way that I was and am, i would have cried due to feeling so sorry for my doll. Than the seed of fear would have also been planted that I too may become homeless. Im not saying I want to keep my daughter ignorant to the world, but I dont want her to worry at a young age. I feel it is a parents responsibility to teach their children compassion and empathy for those less fortunate, but im not crazy about the idea of marketing a doll like that. Maybe if some of the proceeds went to helping the homeless it might be a little less concerning. What do you ladies think? 

SugarCanesOldProfile --- 17 years ago -

I feel it is a parents responsibility to teach their children compassion and empathy for those less fortunate ^^^ i agree 

Shnookums --- 17 years ago -

Dolls were just that, dolls. Kids used their imagination and the dolls we whatever they wanted them to be. Yes yes! I agree! I guess this company is trying to find a new way to make money so that they themselves don't fall into the economic crisis. I wouldn't buy it for my daughter. Perhaps some parent would. 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

I see your point, and to an extent I agree, but I also think that it's a good thing that they are bringing out this doll as a TOOL to introduce children to this lifestyle. I think parents still need to do their part, but I think that times being like they are and as sad as it is, they are going to need all the help they can get introducing children to these concepts. It's sad, but 'children being children' has changed a lot... and unfortunately means that 'children being children' has integrated Much more adult concepts than it used to. However, along those same lines, little girls have been hosting tea parties and making mud pies for years, Myself included. And you know what? It prepared me in a minute way to host house parties and bake for my husband. It prepares young girls to be adults- to cook and clean and do 'wife' things. And I'm not saying that's wrong, I'm just saying it's been going on for a long time. I personally think that the more gradually they learn these things, the better. 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

I don't have children, but I would buy it for her. 

007 --- 17 years ago -

What do you ladies think? I agree with the company...I mean the American Girl company has so many dolls out there and kids are subject to rich and poor all the time...Disney movies, TV, school, friends etc. As parents we all want to teach our kids what we want them to know but sometimes we forget to touch on certain subjects. I too am guilty of this. My daughter came home flabber gasted that a little boy in her class didn't have a bank account of his own and that his grandparents didn't have one set up for him and that he didn't have a college account. While we've been responsible for doing these things and teaching our kids about saving and bank accounts etc...we've neglected to explain not every can or does this. OOPS I am just glad we DID teach our daughter enough manners not to make the kid feel bad because he didn't have those things. 

LadyE --- 17 years ago -

Okay, I hadn't heard of this so I had to Google it....... MrsWoo, I'm with ya. I don't hate it but I do find it a little unsettling. Then again, I'm also not a big fan of 100 dolls to begin with! The article I read was left open to comments so I'm stealing it cause the sarcasm made me giggle. "....coming next Trixie… the teenage streetwalker doll… messed up by her stepfather and turned out by her alcoholic mother, Trixie tries to find her way on the hard avenue of the modern American dream....." 

007 --- 17 years ago -

"....coming next Trixie… the teenage streetwalker doll… messed up by her stepfather and turned out by her alcoholic mother, Trixie tries to find her way on the hard avenue of the modern American dream....." Now THIS I would have a little problem with. A 'poor' doll...teaching kids that not everyone was born with a silver spoon up their arse I'm ok with hahah! 

Vicky (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

i wish i had accounts for my girls...if jenn doesn't get a scholarship, she doesn't go to college...simple as that.... 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

I agree with 007, as usual. I would have a problem with that. The poor doll, not so much. I think it's a good idea. I mean, they make dolls to help explain homosexuality, child abuse, etc. I feel like this is a good thing if used correctly. I think I'm going to buy her. 

007 --- 17 years ago -

i wish i had accounts for my girls...if jenn doesn't get a scholarship, she doesn't go to college...simple as that.... What about student loans and FAFSA and grants?? 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

I'll give her a home. :D 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

i wish i had accounts for my girls...if jenn doesn't get a scholarship, she doesn't go to college...simple as that.... Don't worry Vicky. I'm a student at East Carolina University. As long as you make under a certain amount, she will have grants etc. Now, she will have school loans probably (I do), but they are manageable. You don't pay them back til 6 months after you graduate. My family doesn't make a lot of money (at all), so I got financial aid. Jenn probably will too. PLUS, if her Daddy is a veteran (or you) she will be covered. :D 

mommy of 2 boys♥ --- 17 years ago -

What about student loans and FAFSA and grants?? they're all bs. student loans have interest rates out the a$$, fafsa just sees what grants you qualify for, and they are picky on handing out grants! 

007 --- 17 years ago -

Any little bit helps when you have to pay for it all out of pocket I would think?? 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

they're all bs. student loans have interest rates out the a$$, fafsa just sees what grants you qualify for, and they are picky on handing out grants! I have both of those and I have no trouble with it. I don't consider 6% interest, interest out the @$$. 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

Any little bit helps when you have to pay for it all out of pocket I would think?? True 

007 --- 17 years ago -

Nearly every student is eligible for some form of financial aid, including low-interest Federal Stafford and/or parent PLUS loans, regardless of income or circumstances....so FAFSA helping determine that isn't BS...it's doing it all at the same time in one place. GRANTS never have to be paid back so it's FREE money...hardly BS to me and FAFSA isn't the only place you can apply for grants. and my student loans are at 4.5% pretty low and I'm not paying them back until I graduate...again not really BS. I'm thinking somewhere we started thinking of 2 different things mommy of 2 boys? 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

and my student loans are at 4.5% pretty low and I'm not paying them back until I graduate...again not really BS. Again... True. Me as well. 

WooTang (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

"....coming next Trixie… the teenage streetwalker doll… messed up by her stepfather and turned out by her alcoholic mother, Trixie tries to find her way on the hard avenue of the modern American dream..... Im getting a good chuckle out of that one!! Like you said Lady E I dont hate it and am not going to make it my mission to cause a stink, im just not crazy about it. Lela- I do see the point to helping to make them aware. Your right it just needs to be used correctly I guess I have just seen so many people go to the extremes in being pc or such that i feel like childrens toys are becoming too adult. 

mommy of 2 boys♥ --- 17 years ago -

umm no considering i'm paying on student loans that were offered through the fafsa. i had to use my parents income the whole time even though i didn't live at home. they make squat and i still didn't get sh!t. some people get lucky but know a lot who got screwed. parent plus loans only work if your parents have good enough credit to them. 

007 --- 17 years ago -

Oh I see... I was on my own and used my own credit, picked my own lender etc. Sorry you got screwed. Sometimes you need to do a little research before you start. Schools try to get kickbacks and offer 'programs' to students that help them and not the students. There was a law passed a few years ago lowering the rate of your loans if you called the companies before a certain date for certain loans. 

mommy of 2 boys♥ --- 17 years ago -

nope didn't get it. and it hasn't been that long. i started in 04. my crap is high. and they still do it. until your 25 or married you have to use your parents info for the fafsa. and military doesn't get you no where unless you are active duty or using money from a parent and even then there is A LOT of circumstances that go with that. 

Nik.Nik♥™ --- 17 years ago -

I answered my own question... the doll is cute.. the book may be touching to some girls. I'd buy it for my daughter If i had one 

Vicky (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

We are trying for Craven Seed scholarships, Teaching Fellows Scholarships, other scholarships, and Pell Grants. I am hoping she can get enough to pay for her to stay in a dorm. *crosses fingers Worse comes to worse, I will just have to take out loans.... 

007 --- 17 years ago -

nope didn't get it. and it hasn't been that long. i started in 04. my crap is high. and they still do it. until your 25 or married you have to use your parents info for the fafsa. and military doesn't get you no where unless you are active duty or using money from a parent and even then there is A LOT of circumstances that go with that. I can see where this is going so I'll bow out after this...but I wasn't 25 and I wasn't married and I didn't use my parent's income when I started school the first time... because I had a kid...you forgot that one. AND The military will give you a $6000 GRANT that you dont have to pay back and you also have the option to use your husband's college money with exceptions of course...check into that since you've had such a bad experience other wise, it might help you out ;-) 

IED --- 17 years ago -

I think it is important to teach children, and people in general, that people earn respect not for their station in life, but how they conduct themselves, and drive themselves to better their station in life. If the American Girl Doll Company dignifies those less fortunate, I definitely don't see a problem with that, however there IS one thing that bothers me about things like this. Though unspoken, they often open the door to conversations about charity. Often, those in the position to be charitable are led to believe that charity is a requirement for "being a good person". I see charity by guilt as pity instead of genuine concern for your fellow man. Speaking of dolls, did you hear about the Democrat from West Virginia who wanted to BAN Barbie dolls earlier this year? That's right - he wanted to put a law forth to make them illegal to sell in his state! Barbie Doll sales ban in West Virginia introduced This guy said Barbie and similar dolls "promote or influence girls to place an undue importance on physical beauty to the detriment of their intellectual and emotional development." He's basing his judgment on appearance alone. What, just because Barbie LOOKS beautiful means she automatically lacks brains? FYI, Barbie isn't my cup of tea, but she is universally recognized as being unfairly beautiful. The whole thing seems ridiculous to me. If Barbie is such a bad influence, how about letting the consumer decide to NOT support or buy her products instead of using the government to ban something this ridiculous? He's trying to ban something based off HIS OPINION instead of any sort of FACT! So, what is the solution here? How do you make the doll appear intelligent? Would you give her accessories that are stereotypes of those who seem intelligent? Perhaps Barbie could come with glasses, a calculator and a book on quantum physics? I know it's unrelated, but I figured a doll thread would be a good soapbox. 

mommy of 2 boys♥ --- 17 years ago -

i wasn't married. sh!t i know someone who didn't live of her parents and has a kid and still has to use er parents info bc she's under 25. just saying what we were told 

007 --- 17 years ago -

I answered my own question... the doll is cute.. the book may be touching to some girls. I'd buy it for my daughter If i had one K has a few dolls couldn't tell you where the books are though. If you do have a girl...save your $! The dolls stay in the boxes and countless fights have errupted because K doesn't want B messing up the dolls cause they were so much money and are so special. 

007 --- 17 years ago -

We are trying for Craven Seed scholarships, Teaching Fellows Scholarships, other scholarships, and Pell Grants. I am hoping she can get enough to pay for her to stay in a dorm. *crosses fingers Worse comes to worse, I will just have to take out loans.... I thought there was an NC state program for teaching where they would almost pay for the whole program?? Doesn't NC need teachers? Like MAD BAD? LOL 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground