Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: WWYD

who's talking here?

~*MarLa Singer*~ 1
Tomsgirl02 3
Vicky 1
Little Miss Knowitall 1
Jacky 3
MojaveBurning 1
Muse 3
007 1
IED 3
Crystal 4
*Lauren* 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: WWYD

Ok. So my 10 year old is wanting to buy shoes that are actually bigger than the size he wears. We went to get him shoes last night. He picked them out but then he took the box and replaced the shoes with a size 5 1/2 shoe (he wears a 4). I noticed once we got home. Now, should I take the shoes back and exchange them for a size 4 or would this lesson best be learned by me taking the shoes that he picked out back and getting him a pair of my choosing?

Replace them with the correct size Vote
 
 21.4% (3)
Replace them with a pair of my choosing Vote
 
 42.9% (6)
Other Vote
 
 35.7% (5)
Muse --- 17 years ago -

Ok. So my 10 year old is wanting to buy shoes that are actually bigger than the size he wears. We went to get him shoes last night. He picked them out but then he took the box and replaced the shoes with a size 5 1/2 shoe (he wears a 4). I noticed once we got home. Now, should I take the shoes back and exchange them for a size 4 or would this lesson best be learned by me taking the shoes that he picked out back and getting him a pair of my choosing? 

Crystal --- 17 years ago -

Is there something about the shoes that you dont like? Did he do it on purpose? If so, why? Were the size 4's too snug maybe? Just seems weird that he would try to sneak a bigger size, if you already okay'd him to have them? Maybe I'm not reading something right (it's early) 

Jacky --- 17 years ago -

Get the 4 1/2. It's quit possible that he just wanted them to last longer. 

IED --- 17 years ago -

That's very odd. Did you talk to him and ask WHY he did that? Wanted them to last longer? Other kids his age have bigger feet than him? Did he disobey you in any way by choosing a bigger size? If so, I would say pick out his shoes for him. If not, I would say just get him the proper size. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

No, we've argued this point many times. He wears a 3 and a half. He's been fighting with us for weeks now because his friends all wear their shoes too big. He wanted to get a 6 and we told him no. He does NOT weat a 5 1/2. He did it because his friends wear shoes that are too big. They fit him fine. We told him that he could pick his own shoes out but that he had to get the correct size. We said he could get a 4 or a 4 1/2 when he is clearly a 3 1/2. He then said okay, picked them out and put 5 1/2's in the box that said 4. 

*Lauren* --- 17 years ago -

Let him wear the big shoes. He will have to walk around in umcomfy shoes all day and learn on his own that it wasnt as "cool" as he originally thought. 

IED --- 17 years ago -

What's the new trend of wearing bigger shoes? Is it so you can trip and fall on your face? Is this another fad, like sagging pants, that originated in prisons? If you argued with him about it and he defied you [AND apparently attempted to deceive you!], I'd recommend picking out a pair for him. They don't have to be purple, but you get the idea. Seriously, you could get him a nice, plain, neutral colored pair of shoes in the the proper size and if he complains, tell him next time they WILL be a color of your choosing. You're the mom, though. :) Usually when talking and trying to rationalize, yelling, spanking and grounding don't work, embarrassing them in front of friends will. If he's wearing clown shoes already though, I don't know how you're going to pull that off. 

MojaveBurning --- 17 years ago -

He will have to walk around in umcomfy shoes all day and learn on his own that it wasnt as "cool" as he originally thought. i agree. but maybe add on some punishment for dishonesty? no tv or something for a couple days? 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

I wouldn't get him shoes that were questionable. THey would be nice, solid shoes. They just wouldn't be the ones he wanted. I think I like both ideas so I'll run them by my husband. 

Tomsgirl02 --- 17 years ago -

I would come up with a punishment for being sneaky and dishonest...and honestly..for his safety..I would probably take them back...BUT...I am strict like that...lol... maybe a talk about being an individual too....heck I don't know...lol... 

Crystal --- 17 years ago -

Too expensive to let him wear shoes that are too big.. I never heard of that particular trend (though I'm not suprised to hear it).. My vote is OFFICIALLY, take them back, get good comfy/sturdy shoes for him. None of that fancy crap the kids are wearing. Just something that is made for walking/standing/bicycling or whatever the heck your kid does on a daily bases.. His feet with thank you in the long run.. He's 10, he needs to learn to respect you or face the consequences now (before he turns 13.. lol). 

IED --- 17 years ago -

Tell him to ask Dad what basic training would have been like with a pair of boots that were 2 sizes too big. 

Crystal --- 17 years ago -

maybe a talk about being an individual too This is good advice as well. Tell him to find his own self verus be like everyone else. Hand him the box of shoes (I'd keep the old box and put the new but different shoes in it as a punishment too) and send him out into the world. Tough Love Kid.. Tough Love. 

Crystal --- 17 years ago -

Tell him to ask Dad what basic training would have been like with a pair of boots that were 2 sizes too big. Worse.. make him rub Dad's feet! lol 

007 --- 17 years ago -

replace the shoes with the correct size and punish him for trying to deceive you in a way you see fit. I generally don't care what the other kids are doing and I HATE it when my 9 yo tells me "well my friends" blah blah blah. Well you aren't your friends so there... I hope you figure it out ;-) What a weird 'trend' 

*Lauren* --- 17 years ago -

Worse.. make him rub Dad's feet! lol Hahaha I used to get out of grounding by doing that all the time!!! My dad always had me rub his feet....I actually like rubbing feet now. lol 

Jacky --- 17 years ago -

Buy him a pair of your choosing and make him write sentences. My 9 yr old HATES writing sentences. 

Tomsgirl02 --- 17 years ago -

not to disagree...but I think if she buys a pair of HER choosing...he just won't wear them...he will choose old ones...or other ones in his closet..then it's a waste of money....KWIM?? punish him for the deception...but buy him the shoes he wanted...just in the correct size...JMO... 

Vicky (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

I voted OTHER and my opinion would be to get him the 4 or 4 1/2 as originally agreed upon, but (and here is the kicker).... MAKE HIM TAKE THEM BACK TO THE STORE AND ADMIT TO DECEIVING THE STORE. TELL HIM THAT HE HAS TO FACE THE MANAGER AND ADMIT TO STEALING THE SHOES BECAUSE HE CHANGED THE SIZE IN THE BOX... (of course talk with the manager beforehand so they don't just say "it's okay honey".) Have the manager make up a punishment like "You are banned from shopping here for 30 days or something) Technically it is stealing.... 

Tomsgirl02 --- 17 years ago -

GREAT idea Vicky....love that! My mom made me take back stickers I stole from a bible book store as a child...I will NEVER forget that... 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 17 years ago -

Did your 10 yr old NEED new shoes or did he just want them? If he NEEDED them, then I would return for the correct size. If he WANTED them, I would return them and he would get nothing. Alternatively, you could just hold on to them until they fit. 

Jacky --- 17 years ago -

Alternatively, you could just hold on to them until they fit. This is a good punishment to me. He can have them... next year. LOL 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 17 years ago -

Kids are so cute. I wouldn't take it too seriously, I'd just tell him not to do that again, because he needs shoes that fit him properly, explain to him that he could get hurt if he wears shoes that are too big, take them back and get the correct size. Maybe a half a size up? Maybe the 4s are tight, or maybe he has a wide foot and needs a wide pair. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground