Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: What do you think about this controversial "Illegal Alien" costume

who's talking here?

SugarCanesOldProfile 9
~*MarLa Singer*~ 17
Vicky 2
Jewels 5
Noel 7
Vanishing Act 33
Jacky 29
Muse 2
LelaBelle 7
champatlife 1
LadyE 7
IED 9
Crystal 1
*Lauren* 28
Cindy. 14
Nickname 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: What do you think about this controversial "Illegal Alien" costume

http://www.cnn.com/2009/US/10/17/illegal.immigrant.costume/index.htmllink title NEW YORK (CNN) -- Immigrant rights activists are calling on U.S. retailers to stop selling two controversial "Illegal Alien" costumes that have surfaced for Halloween, saying the outfits are a broadside attack on illegal immigrants. The "Illegal Alien" costume was being offered by retailers including Target, Walgreens and Amazon.com. The "Illegal Alien" costume was being offered by retailers including Target, Walgreens and Amazon.com. Click to view previous image 1 of 2 Click to view next image The "Illegal Alien Adult Costume," manufactured by Forum novelties, includes an orange jumpsuit, similar to prison garb, with "Illegal Alien" stamped in black across the chest; a space alien mask; and a fake Green Card. The "Illegal Alien Mask with Hat" also includes a space alien mask, this time with a dark handlebar mustache and a baseball cap. The Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles said it began receiving e-mails from concerned legal immigrants on Friday. In response, CHIRLA wrote a letter asking several retailers, including Target, Walgreens, and Amazon.com, to stop offering the costume. As of Saturday afternoon, Target had pulled the products, and some links to the costumes on other sites were no longer functional. Target said the "Illegal Alien" costume was inadvertently uploaded to its Web site due to a data entry error. "It is never our intent to offend the consumers with the products we offer," a company statement said. The makers of the costumes could not be reached for comment on Saturday. Jorge-Mario Cabrera, the director of communications for CHIRLA, said he initially thought the costume was a stab at harmless satire. But when he saw the Green Card, he realized it was an swipe at illegal immigrants. "This was an ignorant attempt to poke fun at a small community," said Cabrera. Political satire and Halloween often merge. Costumes depicting former well-known political figures are often seen along side those depicting Batman or Wonder Woman. To some, the attempted humor of the costumes falls flat. Guillermo Iglesias said both of his parents were illegal immigrants in the United States. He felt the costumes were offensive because they depicted illegal immigrants as "not one of us." "I have a lot of illegal immigrant friends," said Iglesias. "If I showed them that costume, it would really hurt them." Despite the controversy, some stores say the costumes have been a hit. "It's a very well-recommended costume," said an employee at Ricky's, a costume store in New York City. The store has sold seven costumes for $39.99 apiece and is set to receive another shipment. William Gheen, the president of Americans for Legal Immigration, said he intends to buy the costume, and calls the reaction unfounded. "The only people getting upset are the hyper-sensitive, over-politically correct, pro-amnesty, illegal alien-supporting nuts," said Gheen. "You can't attack people's freedom in this country." "I think having a costume like that is distasteful," said Andrea Hill, outside of Ricky's. "But if it's not illegal, I think it's alright for them to sell it."

Im offended! Vote
 
 4.0% (1)
Im not offended, but I dont like it. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
I dont care Vote
 
 36.0% (9)
The humor side of it makes it funny! Vote
 
 60.0% (15)
SugarCanesOldProfile --- 17 years ago -

http://www.cnn.com/2009/US/10/17/illegal.immigrant.costume/index.htmllink title NEW YORK (CNN) -- Immigrant rights activists are calling on U.S. retailers to stop selling two controversial "Illegal Alien" costumes that have surfaced for Halloween, saying the outfits are a broadside attack on illegal immigrants. The "Illegal Alien" costume was being offered by retailers including Target, Walgreens and Amazon.com. The "Illegal Alien" costume was being offered by retailers including Target, Walgreens and Amazon.com. Click to view previous image 1 of 2 Click to view next image The "Illegal Alien Adult Costume," manufactured by Forum novelties, includes an orange jumpsuit, similar to prison garb, with "Illegal Alien" stamped in black across the chest; a space alien mask; and a fake Green Card. The "Illegal Alien Mask with Hat" also includes a space alien mask, this time with a dark handlebar mustache and a baseball cap. The Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles said it began receiving e-mails from concerned legal immigrants on Friday. In response, CHIRLA wrote a letter asking several retailers, including Target, Walgreens, and Amazon.com, to stop offering the costume. As of Saturday afternoon, Target had pulled the products, and some links to the costumes on other sites were no longer functional. Target said the "Illegal Alien" costume was inadvertently uploaded to its Web site due to a data entry error. "It is never our intent to offend the consumers with the products we offer," a company statement said. The makers of the costumes could not be reached for comment on Saturday. Jorge-Mario Cabrera, the director of communications for CHIRLA, said he initially thought the costume was a stab at harmless satire. But when he saw the Green Card, he realized it was an swipe at illegal immigrants. "This was an ignorant attempt to poke fun at a small community," said Cabrera. Political satire and Halloween often merge. Costumes depicting former well-known political figures are often seen along side those depicting Batman or Wonder Woman. To some, the attempted humor of the costumes falls flat. Guillermo Iglesias said both of his parents were illegal immigrants in the United States. He felt the costumes were offensive because they depicted illegal immigrants as "not one of us." "I have a lot of illegal immigrant friends," said Iglesias. "If I showed them that costume, it would really hurt them." Despite the controversy, some stores say the costumes have been a hit. "It's a very well-recommended costume," said an employee at Ricky's, a costume store in New York City. The store has sold seven costumes for $39.99 apiece and is set to receive another shipment. William Gheen, the president of Americans for Legal Immigration, said he intends to buy the costume, and calls the reaction unfounded. "The only people getting upset are the hyper-sensitive, over-politically correct, pro-amnesty, illegal alien-supporting nuts," said Gheen. "You can't attack people's freedom in this country." "I think having a costume like that is distasteful," said Andrea Hill, outside of Ricky's. "But if it's not illegal, I think it's alright for them to sell it." 

Jacky --- 17 years ago -

That's freaking hilarious! 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

It is hilarious! And I don't mind offending 'illegals'. If they don't want to be picked on, then leave and come back legal or not at all. I don't think that stores should change their inventory to cater to a few who shouldn't be here ANYWAYS. Why not just take the jail bird costumes away too since we might be offending them? It's the same thing right? Both of them are being picked on for something they did illegally... i.e. being in the country or some other illegal offense. Now I'm all fired up! LOL! 

SugarCanesOldProfile --- 17 years ago -

I mean, there are A LOT of "offensive" costumes, slutty military ones, the couple ones that are very sexual, but seriously if you dont like it dont buy it! I hate when people throw fits over stuff like that. Not everything is politically correct no, But we wouldnt have stand up comedy if it was right. 

Jacky --- 17 years ago -

He felt the costumes were offensive because they depicted illegal immigrants as "not one of us." They aren't one of us. We are American Citizens... and they are not. They should get in the legal way, work the legal way and pay the legal way. Then they would be "one of us" and the costume wouldn't apply to them! 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

They aren't one of us. We are American Citizens... and they are not. They should get in the legal way, work the legal way and pay the legal way. Then they would be "one of us" and the costume wouldn't apply to them! YES! 

LadyE --- 17 years ago -

"The only people getting upset are the hyper-sensitive, over-politically correct, pro-amnesty, illegal alien-supporting nuts," said Gheen. Well, I'm none of those ^^^^ but I thought it was in bad taste. As a legal Mexican American, I don't appreciate the stereotype. Wanna know how many times my husband has been asked if he's legal??? Or how many times we've walked into an all white restaurant around here and LITERALLY had the whole place turn around and look at us? Nothing annoys me more than the perpetuation of stereotypes. 

SugarCanesOldProfile --- 17 years ago -

My father came in illegal, then after came in with a green card, and i STILL find it funny 

LadyE --- 17 years ago -

Cool for you, seriously. I don't. I wasn't stating my opinion to bash anyone elses or to be holier than thou. You asked what people thought and I posted my thoughts. 

SugarCanesOldProfile --- 17 years ago -

oh no im sorry i didnt mean for that to be directed towards YOU at all.. i just wanted to put it out there on MY opinion. sorry missy ♥ 

LadyE --- 17 years ago -

These forums seriously need a tone of voice button. Cause I didn't mean it rude either. Love backatcha 

SugarCanesOldProfile --- 17 years ago -

These forums seriously need a tone of voice button. Cause I didn't mean it rude either. LoL Totally! 

Jacky --- 17 years ago -

Like, for sure! Aha! 

SugarCanesOldProfile --- 17 years ago -

Like, for sure! Aha! lmao 

LelaBelle --- 17 years ago -

I guess I can see both sides. BUT I don't think that it is any more offensive than some other costumes out there. 

*Lauren* --- 17 years ago -

I think if it was a mexican guy in an orange jumpsuite and it said "illegal immigrant" than that would be offensive...but its an alien in a jumpsuit. I think its hysterical. 

Jacky --- 17 years ago -

See, I think if it was a mexican guy in a janitors suit that said illegal immigrant, THAT would be offensive. 

*Lauren* --- 17 years ago -

Or how many times we've walked into an all white restaurant around here and LITERALLY had the whole place turn around and look at us? Just out of curiosity what all white restaurant did you go to? I have not seen any all white place anywhere here. As far as I see this place is very diverse. Please dont take this offensively. Im not being rude, just asking. 

Vicky (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

I think it was mainly making fun of the word "alien" .... like a pun on the word... I don't think it was saying that Mexicans are "one of us" and even that could be a pun... "they are one of "us", but not one of "US" as in US-A.... 

Vicky (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

Double Post.... I DO NOT stutter when I type dang it!!! 

Cindy. --- 17 years ago -

Or how many times we've walked into an all white restaurant around here and LITERALLY had the whole place turn around and look at us? Can you tell me where this has happened? And where you've entered an "all white restaurant" in this area? I mean, I'm white and my husband's Mexican and I think we can count on one hand the number of times we've gotten dirty looks from anyone, ever. And those very few times it has happened, it's been hispanic females directing their nasty looks toward me. Anyway. I also think the costume seems more like a play on the word alien and it's teasing at political correctness more than anything. If I knew someone who was racist and they chose to wear that costume, being offended might be warranted. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 17 years ago -

And where you've entered an "all white restaurant" Yea, please tell me which restaurants are all white? 

champatlife --- 17 years ago -

i like the added greencard, kind of defeats the point alittle.. but funny, and my coworker found it funny 

LadyE --- 17 years ago -

When we lived here before it was at Cafe 24 but it was called something else then. More recent was at some little mom and pop place outside MHC--kinda across from Kurtis Chevrolet. And yeah, when we walked in it was "all white". 

Cindy. --- 17 years ago -

When we lived here before it was at Cafe 24 but it was called something else then. More recent was at some little mom and pop place outside MHC--kinda across from Kurtis Chevrolet. And yeah, when we walked in it was "all white". Are you talking about Kountry Kitchen? If so, they turn around and look at EVERYONE that walks through the door. You're in the SOUTH, that is what people do, especially in tiny places like that. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 17 years ago -

And yeah, when we walked in it was "all white Um maybe at the time you went in it just happened to be that all the patrons were white. You are stereotyping, but yet you claim to dislike stereotypes. That is kind of silly. 

LadyE --- 17 years ago -

Yes. I know how the south works. Grew up in SC. Usually down there, we say hello--even if we're staring ;) 

Noel --- 17 years ago -

Stereotypes are around for a reason. Just because they're offensive doesn't mean they aren't, in some cases, true. I think the costume is harmless fun, and makes it easier to laugh at something that actually is a serious problem. Meanwhile, "Broadside attack on illegal immigrants?" Uhm. . . is this a bad thing? They're doing something ILLEGAL. Why is it that this ALWAYS becomes a sudden moral "gray area" just because it happens to involve minorities? Illegal aliens are doing something wrong, period. No one ever has a problem with people dressing up as ROBBERS on Halloween. But you know what, I do. It's offensive to robbers. They're people, too, guys. Come on. We need a sensitivity coalition for them. Also, Lady_E, I can kind of sympathize. Even my husband doubted me about this until he started paying attention, but when I walk into a restaurant or store with a large Hispanic group, I get stared down by the men. I'm not that concerned about looking conceited, those who know me know I'm nothing of the sort, but a Mexican friend told me that it's a compliment in Mexico if a man stares at you. I certainly hope that's not true, because there's nothing complimentary about it. It's creepy and rude. I don't normally get to say that, because it seems to appear racist, but no one's blasting you for it, so I suppose I'm safe in this thread! 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 17 years ago -

Meanwhile, "Broadside attack on illegal immigrants?" Uhm. . . is this a bad thing? They're doing something ILLEGAL. Why is it that this ALWAYS becomes a sudden moral "gray area" just because it happens to involve minorities? Illegal aliens are doing something wrong, period. Thank you! 

SugarCanesOldProfile --- 17 years ago -

Meanwhile, "Broadside attack on illegal immigrants?" Uhm. . . is this a bad thing? They're doing something ILLEGAL. Why is it that this ALWAYS becomes a sudden moral "gray area" just because it happens to involve minorities? Illegal aliens are doing something wrong, period. Thank you! wohoo! exactly! 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

humor
polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground