Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: spanking???

who's talking here?

GINA 1
Vicky 1
**Kathy with a K** 2
Jacky 1
Muse 1
LelaBelle 3
Truthbetold 1
Dusk2Dawn 1
kristinmarie 1
IED 2
Cookette 5
LuckyMe 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: spanking???

Do you believe in a good 'ol fashion spanking? Or is that child abuse these days? I wanna know your thoughts....I think that i saw something a while back about it but I didnt think it was a poll and I wanna know what you all think.

Good 'ol fashion spanking... Vote
 
 22.5% (9)
I prefer time out... Vote
 
 12.5% (5)
Both... Vote
 
 65.0% (26)
Neither... Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Cookette --- 16 years ago -

Do you believe in a good 'ol fashion spanking? Or is that child abuse these days? I wanna know your thoughts....I think that i saw something a while back about it but I didnt think it was a poll and I wanna know what you all think.  

Cookette --- 16 years ago -

I love how it says "your secret ballot has been recorded"...Its not much of a secret if im the only one that voted lol. 

Jacky --- 16 years ago -

I use both methods - and I couldn't care less if any person or agency considers it child abuse. =) 

Cookette --- 16 years ago -

I had a woman tell me i was abusing my child because I swated her on the butt when she was being a brat. I didnt hurt her. I spooked her was all. I was raised on spankings and I turned out just fine :) Well at least thats what my mom tells me lol 

Truthbetold --- 16 years ago -

If my Kids are out of control and stop listening I whoop as$ and take names lol no but I spank them to get their attention! 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

I do both. It's not child abuse unless the parent is taking out their anger and frustration on their child. If they do something that rates a pop on the butt, they have to come ME. I let myself cool down before I spank them bc I want the spanking to be about what they did and not about my anger. 

Cookette --- 16 years ago -

I had a woman tell me i was abusing my child because I swated her on the butt when she was being a brat. Lol it looks like i said i was spanking the woman....hahaha 

kristinmarie --- 16 years ago -

there is a difference in a spanking. And a beating which i consider to much. I spank both my kids if they need it. They wont run my house. 

Cookette --- 16 years ago -

I do both. Me too. I give Lj a time out for most things but she still doesnt get the whole time out thing. I mean she knows that she sits in her chair but she doesnt hate it Kwim? She isnt scared of me. Now if daddy puts her in the chair she gets all upset. So I end up having to spank her to get her to take me seriously. I always give myself a cool down period tho. I am not out to "hurt" my child. Just make her realize I mean business. 

Vicky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Society takes it to easy on kids these days and that is why were are going to hades in a hand basket... Too much violence on tv because there is less violence (as in discipline) at home.... Too much sex on tv because there is a move towards swinging and no love at home... I see less family values these days and more "it's all about me" in the world... Spank your child, it's the right thing to do. Time out works if you have the fear behind it...so use it too....Discipline is important as is consistency....(which I am guilty of not being)... 

LelaBelle --- 16 years ago -

I believe in spankings. I spank my animals and if my hubby isn't nice to me, I'll swat him too! I was raised on spankings and I NEVER did the things the children seem to get away with now. Did any of you guys throw fits in a restaurant or throw food? I didn't. My mom said "Do we need to go to the restroom?" and that was my warning. One more squeal, cry, or flung pea and I was snatched up, taken into the bathroom and had my hide TANNED! And I didn't do it again. Lesson learned. Spankings all the way! :D 

**Kathy with a K** --- 16 years ago -

I spank as a last resort. "clean your room....is your room clean? Then go clean it.....If I go up there will I think it's clean? No? Then let's go....(a half hour later)....It better be clean before I get to ten...1....2....3....4.....See, that didn't take so long did it?" Maybe I give too many chances, but I really use it as a last resort. I think it has to do with age too. My husband hates watching Super Nanny. Seeing these kids throwing tantrums and hitting parents and eachother. He says "whoop that @$$", don't give them a "naughty seat". 

IED --- 16 years ago -

I say both: either/or, depending on the situation. Let the punishment fit the crime MOST of the time, but also keep in mind that while there is a need for consistency, you have to keep kids guessing, too. If they know they are going to get spanked for something, they may be ready for it. Some kids actually cope with some punishments better than others, and if they know they will "only" get a time out, it may be worth it to them to do whatever warrants that punishment. "A time-out? Big deal. I'll see you in 15 minutes." Find their least favorite punishment. Now make it worse, without dabbling in the realm of genuine child abuse. 

GINA --- 16 years ago -

my kids get a time out and since they are under 5 i put them there for how ever old they are.. so my 4 yr old goes in time out for 4 minutes.. my 2 yr old is 2 minutes.. we actually have a time out chair and a timer.. they do really well with sitting there and if they get up before the timer is up then the timer starts all over again.. my kids hate going in time out.. to them its torture.. but it works great.. 

IED --- 16 years ago -

I remember that there were many punishments for me as I was growing up. Early on, my punishments were time-out and spankings. My mom was not shy about giving me a spank in public, either. That really helped keep me from acting up in public - knowing that the hand could come at any time! "Time Out" was standing, quietly, with my nose in the corner of the room, usually for 5-15 minutes. Spankings were common, but went away as I got older. "The Belt" was a rarity, reserved for those really bad occasions. I think the first time it was given I was 4 or 5. I don't remember what I did. The last time I got it, I was 12. I remember I traveled MILES from home with friends, was out way past dark, without checking-in or calling home for hours upon hours. My parents were worried enough that they called the police. I was also grounded for [I think] a month. "The switch" was also a rarity that I only got once or twice. Slapping was given sometimes, especially on-the-spot for talking back or cussing. A "talking to" or grounding was usually given for things like getting a grade lower than I was capable in school. A spanking might come from a disciplinary problem at school. Something "long-term" was given a "long-term" punishment, where something quick was given a quick punishment. Most of the time, that's how it worked. Sometimes I would get both, though. I also hated reading when I was a kid. It was terrible, to come home from school and be grounded, banished to a room full of books! Wake up, school, home, homework, dinner, bed. No video games, computers, telephones, cell phones, or TVs. At best, I had a clock radio, but I didn't like much music when I was younger, either! I think my parents were pretty good at disciplining me. 

LelaBelle --- 16 years ago -

I loved reading. But I know children who had to copy the dictionary or the Bible. The Bible is difficult to take a stance on: Yes, the learn the Bible while they are copying, No, the Lord's Word should not be used as punishment. Either way, they said it sucked. 

**Kathy with a K** --- 16 years ago -

During the summer if I got grounded, and I usually did, I'd get sent outside and have to sit on our porch swing in the awful heat and read. Not having the comfort of AC was my punishment. And once I had to sit in the middle of the livingroom on the floor and do nothing aaaallllll daaaaaayyyy for a week!!! My friends would come to the door and my Mom would rub it in that I was being punished and couldn't play then she'd make me tell them what I did wrong. I don't remember what I did wrong but I do remember it being humiliating. I try to make every effort to not humiliate my girls when they get disciplined. 

Dusk2Dawn --- 16 years ago -

I do not spare the rod, but it's a last resort. Sometimes from what I see with some of these kids I see.....geez! They need a spanking on the spot. I'm have old school in me. 

LelaBelle --- 16 years ago -

I'm pretty old school too. 

LuckyMe --- 16 years ago -

Given the ages of my kids, I will share that I voted TIME OUT. However, before they were this age, I completely agreed with spankings. Now, I prefere Time Out and Grounding. I don't have to use either often. Maybe because I spanked before now. LOL :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground