Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Opinions!

who's talking here?

Vicky 1
Life is Great! 2
Little Miss Knowitall 2
Muse 6
Tricia 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Opinions!

We're not talking about military situations here, btw. Okay, I had to write an arbitration statement on this topic and I'm interested in what others think. Let's say there is a manager at a large "web" company (e-commerce, etc). The company begins to lay off people and the manager feels that during the lay offs there are gender and age discriminations taking place. He also feels that there are new policies put into place that creates unfair treatment of lower level employees. He raised his concerns to his superiors several times and nothing happened. SO on his DOWN time, when he was off from work, he created a satirical website that basically mocks and makes fun of this fictional company modeled after the one he works for. The company found out. Now, question is if he should be fired or not? Thoughts?

Yes, he should be fired Vote
 
 18.2% (2)
No, he should not Vote
 
 72.7% (8)
Idk Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Maybe Vote
 
 9.1% (1)
Muse --- 16 years ago -

We're not talking about military situations here, btw.

Okay, I had to write an arbitration statement on this topic and I'm interested in what others think.

Let's say there is a manager at a large "web" company (e-commerce, etc). The company begins to lay off people and the manager feels that during the lay offs there are gender and age discriminations taking place. He also feels that there are new policies put into place that creates unfair treatment of lower level employees.

He raised his concerns to his superiors several times and nothing happened. SO on his DOWN time, when he was off from work, he created a satirical website that basically mocks and makes fun of this fictional company modeled after the one he works for.

The company found out. Now, question is if he should be fired or not?

Thoughts? 

Tricia --- 16 years ago -

Reminds me of General McChrystal, yet in a not-so-severe situation. I don't think he should get fired for having an opinion. Besides, does his opinion jeopardize the integrity of the company and its workers? I'm thinking not. I don't want to play the hippie, but isn't what he did his right: freedom of speech? 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

That's what I thought, Tricia. My ruling was that he was completely within his constitutional rights to do what he did.

But another person has the argument that even though he has freedom of speech, he should maintain a level of professionalism and regard for the company he works for. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

I have a personal saying, "Never apologize for your opinion; only the delivery" 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

The person in question is not covered under the constitution for his remarks/"satire" about a private company.

Depending on where the person was employed, the company can fire "at will" - for any reason or no reason at all. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

private company.



But his remarks were about a fictional company, not the one he works for.

IT doesn't say what state he's in 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

If the similarities were such that the fictional company can be figured out to be the employer, then they really weren't about a fictional company at all. 

Life is Great! --- 16 years ago -

If the similarities were such that the fictional company can be figured out to be the employer, then they really weren't about a fictional company at all.

This is why I said yes, he should be fired.

Was his blog set to "private"? 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

It wasn't really a blog. More like an online magazine. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

It was not private. In fact, it gained a lot of visitors 

Life is Great! --- 16 years ago -

I'm on the fence. As a person I would be pizzed because that is my freedom of speech, however, if one person was smart enough to figure out who the guy was there surely were more and that looks bad on your company. I'd be mad if I were the owner of the company as well. 

Vicky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

If there is a company policy that states he cannot demean or disparage the company then he should be fired. If not, then maybe disciplinary action if the company felt it was damaging. Ultimately, many states are a "no cause" state and can fire without cause....

I have been told more often than not that if I don't like something...."there's the door".... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground