Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Question about "The Craigslist Killer"

who's talking here?

Shnookums 1
Kaci 2
Noel 7
Vanishing Act 3
Nikita 1
Ja Ja Jacky 2
Jersey Girl 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Jersey Girl --- 15 years ago -

I DVR'd it and haven't watched it yet.

I'm debating on letting L watch it so she knows what could happen on the internet. She spends a lot of time on the computer and I want her to know the seriousness of it.

Yes, I plan on watching it first but I want to know what anyone who's seen it thinks is an appropriate age to watch it. 

Vanishing Act --- 15 years ago -

I have not seen it but going over the dangers is most definitely a good idea. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

I know I shouldn't even be in these threads, but if I could venture the, "zomg, you have no kids, you may as well be blind" opinion . . .

I'd let her watch it -especially- if it was a little gory/intense. She'll remember that. She won't go, "Oh, great, another cheesy, emabarassingly-acted movie like the ones they show is in school about why we shouldn't have sex at our age, yawn."

As far as I REMEMBER, kids hate to be played down to, and it took only ONE video (staged) of a child being hit by a bus and the mother falling to SH*T afterwards . . . to make me look both ways EVERY time I cross a street for my entire adult life. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

I watched a movie called Strangeland as a 13-year-old.

I'm CAREFUL on the internet. CARE. FUL. 

Jersey Girl --- 15 years ago -

Noel, you should know that I am not going to say your opinion doesn't matter because you have no kids.

I just remember that as a child, my brother sat on me and held me down to watch Freddy Kruger and I had nightmares for a VERY long time. I didn't want to take showers because I thought he was going to come out the faucet, I used to run and jump on the bed because I thought he might come out from under the bed, I didn't even like to sit on the toilet because I immediately thought about the movie.

I *think* I was about 7. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

See, that's effed up. That's turning a movie into torture - DEFINITELY different! And horror movies like that TOY with your psychology, that's why you fear them coming into reality.


But showing the potential gory aspect of real life scenarios, and being encouraged and talked to about it by an understanding and concerned mother, is very different than being forced to watch a slasher fic.


Ask her, during the intense scenes, "Do you need to pause it for a minute?" And if she says yes, use that minute to dialogue.

"I know it's upsetting, but this has happened, to intelligent, innocent people. We need you to know that you COULD, one day, be in danger, and knowing the signs could save your life." 

Jersey Girl --- 15 years ago -

I asked on FB too and a friend of mine (who has 3 kids) said it's probably a good idea along with two other friends.

I had planned on watching it tonight but haven't gotten a chance. 

Vanishing Act --- 15 years ago -

Oh my goodness Noel.. I saw Strangeland! I was probably about the same age! Scary stuff! 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

. I saw Strangeland!

I hate to say it, but that movie is what introduced me to bondage, pain fetishizing and body modification, so it will always hold a special place in my heart. But, teenage hormones (which are hard enough when you DON'T add on discovering that you're a kink freak . . . >.>) aside, I understood the message, and I LEARNED from that movie. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I think there are better alternatives. I don't think she needs to watch how many women be tortured and brutally murdered? There are a ton of movies on lifetime, based on real life evens just like this one, that will get the same point across that will have a lot less violence. And I certainly think one of those would be enough to scare the crap out of her. 

Kaci --- 15 years ago -

In the movie it doesn't show him like brutally murdering anyone he shoots them but it doesn't show the ppl he's shooting while he's shooting them or after so IMO it's not gory at all and the language isn't bad and I mean after all it did come on lifetime lol!
I'm not sure how old your daughter is but I think if shes old enough to be on the computer alone shes old enough to be taught that the person on the other side of the screen isn't always who they say they are! 

Jersey Girl --- 15 years ago -

I wouldn't allow my children to watch it, not at this age. If you ARE going to let her watch it, make sure you watch it first so you know what to expect. 

Yeah, I planned on it. I just want her to know what could happen. She has given her number out 1 time and I had to yell at her for it.

I'm not sure how old your daughter is but I think if shes old enough to be on the computer alone shes old enough to be taught that the person on the other side of the screen isn't always who they say they are! 

She's 11 but she has already hit puberty and is very mature for her age. 

Shnookums --- 15 years ago -

I can't remember every detail of the movie, but I think it would be ok to let her watch it. It was more focused on him and his issues rather than the crimes themselves. I don't recall bad language. When they show the girls they are covered up and nothing sexual shown.

Don't yell at me anyone if I'm wrong. Just going off of memory here..... 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I haven't actually seen the movie but I was told it was brutal.... of course that is subject to opinion. If it doesn't show the murders actually happening, then I would say it's safe to let L watch it. 

Jersey Girl --- 15 years ago -

Ok, I guess I'm going to watch it now then. 

Jersey Girl --- 15 years ago -

So, I watched half and haven't seen anything bad other than some women dressed sexy.

I don't know.. still debating. 

Kaci --- 15 years ago -

Yea and I've seen women dressed worse then that at walmart lol! 

Jersey Girl --- 15 years ago -

I have the magazines with the articles about the kids being bullied, but I didn't want to show her that yet because they talk about 2 guys having sex. I've had the sex talk with her, but not the gay/lesbian talk.

Yes, I know that I will have to talk to her about it but I just wanted to show her what could happen. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -


To me, it's more important (and more relevant)


I don't know, I think potential abduction and rape is just as important and relevant as bullying and suicide. They both happen to girls L's age all over the country. I can't see saying one is more or less important than the other.

Looks like there's some deliberation on this one, Julie - everyone has a different opinion, so in the end you just have to remember that you know your daughter better than anyone else, and YOU know what's appropriate for her more than anyone else. What doesn't work for Maria might work for you, what doesn't work for Kaci might work for you.

Though I do agree that if she's old enough to be online unsupervised, she's old enough to see the potential consequences. Like I said, I remember being her age, and being played down to with muted effects and "family friendly" acting and story retellings just made me bored and resentful. 

Vanishing Act --- 15 years ago -

J.. I was online unsupervised at 12 and could have gotten myself into a lot of dangerous situations.. My parents gave me the "don't give out information it's not safe" speech but didn't get to graphic or scary and I was giving out my HOME PHONE NUMBER at 12!!! At 13 (before watching strangeland) I was stalked and followed to my friends house and still gave my information out (grade and school.. along with pictures that was identifying enough that people could find me) and didn't learn until I actually watched something as scary as strangeland. So if you are concerned she will give out any info and she is willing to watch the movie .. I would let her. With you sitting with her to answer any questions or to turn it off if it is to much for her. 

Nikita --- 15 years ago -

in the end you just have to remember that you know your daughter better than anyone else, and YOU know what's appropriate for her more than anyone else.

this is true. do what you think is best.

I only watched half of it, and thought it was good. I need to watch it from the beginning. 

Jersey Girl --- 15 years ago -

So if you are concerned she will give out any info and she is willing to watch the movie .. I would let her. With you sitting with her to answer any questions or to turn it off if it is to much for her. 

I am concerned. She has given out her number before. It was another girl who plays on her game (I listened to the message) but it's still to someone in California that she didn't know. And the other girl was 15 when she was 10. 

Jersey Girl --- 15 years ago -

Ok, so I watched it all the way through and while it sends a message I don't think that was what I was looking for.

I wanted her to know what could happen, but not what could happen when you solicit your "services".

Julie, is she asking to watch it? 

No. But if she did, I'd let her watch it because it didn't show anything major. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

I wanted her to know what could happen, but not what could happen when you solicit your "services".


Lol. There's always Strangeland.

Buuuut I don't think that'd get by any momma sensibilities but my own, if I had kids. :p 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

STRANGELAND - DEE SCHNIDER'S, TRAILER Uploaded by chefandew . - Full seasons and entire episodes online. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground