Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Opinions

who's talking here?

~*MarLa Singer*~ 2
Shnookums 1
Vicky 2
Noel 6
Vanishing Act 2
Little Miss Knowitall 2
Ja Ja Jacky 7
proud2Busmc 1
GroomingMyWay 1
Jersey Girl 1
L I G 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Opinions

In one of my classes, we're discussing police conduct. In this video, forget what the media is SAYING. Just watch and see the actions of the police and the woman. In your opinion, is it justified that they were fired or suspended?

Yes Vote
 
 70.6% (12)
No Vote
 
 23.5% (4)
Maybe Vote
 
 5.9% (1)
GroomingMyWay --- 15 years ago -

I Say fire them...thats just bad behavior and if its not adressed then it will continue.. i dont care if the lady is drunk and making pases at the officers they should have been more professional.. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I agree with how it was handled as well. There was NO reason for them to take photos, lift up her skirt, put their hands on her or anything else. The whole situation is disgusting. The woman is disgusting and certainly not a victim. The men are disgusting. They collectively took advantage of a drunk woman - when really she was publicly intoxicated and should have been arrested or at least a cab called and a warning given. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 15 years ago -

If they were all consenting adults I don't see a problem, other than the police doing this while at work.

Do I find them all gross? Yes. But do I think peoples careers and lives should have been changed over this?
Certainly not. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 15 years ago -

she was publicly intoxicated and should have been arrested or at least a cab called and a warning given.

0 

Vanishing Act --- 15 years ago -

If they were all consenting adults I don't see a problem, other than the police doing this while at work.

Do I find them all gross? Yes. But do I think peoples careers and lives should have been changed over this?
Certainly not.



That would be okay if they weren't cops who are suppose to uphold the law and are also working. You can get sexual harrassment charges and fired from Burger king by doing those same things at work so why would a cop be allowed to do that? 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

You can get sexual harrassment charges and fired from Burger king by doing those same things at work so why would a cop be allowed to do that?



True true. Their job is to serve and protect the community - not serve themselves. They knew what they were doing and they deserve to be fired. Men will be men is not a sufficient excuse. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

That's some sht Boom - effed up! 

Vicky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

she was publicly intoxicated and should have been arrested or at least a cab called and a warning given.

she wasn't publicly intoxicated... She was in a private car when the driver was arrested and the police transported her to the station to call someone and get a ride home.

It was inappropriate, firing was justified, suspension for allowing it to happen in thier presence and not reporting it was not strong enough and the resigination should not have been allowed.

Sexual harassment is sexual harassment whether or not someone with diminshed mental state willingly participated or not. She clearly did not participate in all of it because she sat down rather quickly when the guy tried to take pictures from behind.... 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

she wasn't publicly intoxicated... She was in a private car when the driver was arrested and the police transported her to the station to call someone and get a ride home.



I missed that part.

The fact still remains that they were supposed to be helping her and they were instead helping themselves to her goods. 

Vicky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Totally agree CJ! They should have been fired and the one who physically touched should have been charged........

Using a position of public trust to a sexual advantage....

They had to know where the flipping cameras were AND... what the heck is on the monitor of the one guy who offers her a drink????? 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

AND... what the heck is on the monitor of the one guy who offers her a drink?????


OMG! You are right! I had to go back and watch it. 

Vanishing Act --- 15 years ago -

Wow just went back and watched that again! 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 15 years ago -

If they were all consenting adults I don't see a problem, other than the police doing this while at work.


If she's drunk, does she have the ability to consent? 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 15 years ago -

Um yes, drunk people can consent. I fail to see anyone being harassed here. She looks as though she is having a good time, too.
lol My whole 21st year of life is a blur but I will say this, whenever I was out drinking with my friends I was never unable to consent or say NO to ANYTHING due to being drunk.

The fact of the matter is that the whole deal is wrong because it was done at the police station, and with police officers who were on duty.

They should be written up but not fired. Nobody did anything illegal, imo. 

Jersey Girl --- 15 years ago -

The fact of the matter is that the whole deal is wrong because it was done at the police station, and with police officers who were on duty.

They should be written up but not fired. Nobody did anything illegal, imo. 


I completely agree. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

Um yes, drunk people can consent.

That may be true, but not all of them. This poll can't really be answered by any of us, because we have no idea what her alcohol tolerance is, or if she was beyond the place where rational thinking and comprehension of a situation were still possible for her, personally. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

Men will be men is not a sufficient excuse.


Also very true. Alcohol is pretty well-known for making people amorous when they might otherwise not be.

As police officers, they were aware of that, and they were also aware of the fact that, without testing, they have no way of knowing that it was just alcohol (didn't watch the video yet to see if it was mentioned) in her system.

Even if she was flirtatious and coming on to them because she made the choice of her own free will to drink that much, -they- knew she was drunk, and they knew there was a chance it was taking advantage. 

L I G --- 15 years ago -

Let's face ... police brutality is not nice, but sometimes it's needed. Have you ever met some of the people that get in trouble with the law? Hell, 4 out of 5 days of the week I have to remind myself that it's not okay to whoop their assses.

When these people are punching, kicking, biting, trying to stab a cop then, IMO, they need a good asss whoopin'.

ETA: I didn't watch the video so IDK what it's about. I'm just speaking on police brutality. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

ETA: I didn't watch the video so IDK what it's about.

What they're being arrested for doing is conveniently not filmed by the camera man.

All we see, when it first opens, is one woman grabbing and wrestling with the cops hands, and him trying to get free, then another woman comes over and physically separates them, gets in front of him, and he punches her, which knocks her back across the car hood, to cuff her. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

But let me also add my sound is down, so I'm not hearing any of the back story. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

They should be written up but not fired. Nobody did anything illegal, imo.


People get fired for doing things that aren't illegal often. Cops are one of the very few professions that SHOULD be held to a higher standard. What they did is waaaaaay beyond morally wrong. I would get fired for that... as would a school teacher or a McDonalds employee. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Yeah that cop was a loser. 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

They were arrested for JAYWALKING. Yes, they were resisting arrest but he punched her square in the face. It wasn't a gut reaction to being hit by the woman. He pauses, breathes and THEN punches her closed fist in the face

Like I said, my sound was down. Is there a news broadcast playing over the video?

And, yeah, if that brief, 5-second exchange REALLY was ALL there was to that, if the camera didn't start rolling late in the game, if those women were not slapping, smacking, threatening or fighting him for any more than what we see, he is, most definitely, a loser, and likely not fit to be a cop.

I just don't always trust a video, you know? Not right off the bat, anyway. Especially when the greatest moment of drama comes up first things first. 

proud2Busmc --- 15 years ago -

I just don't always trust a video, you know? Not right off the bat, anyway. Especially when the greatest moment of drama comes up first things first.

^^This

He was alone in the middle of a group of people, trying his best to arrest girl #1 with her going crazy and he didnt cause physical harm to her so I dont think he had malicious intent. Do I think he should have punched her? NO WAY but at the same time anyone who has been in a physical confrontation knows how adrenaline is pumping. He was outnumbered and being heckled form all angles about "ripping her clothes off" and "slammin on her man" meanwhile none of that would have happened if she didnt resist arrest and act a damn fool. Girl #2 was wrong for involving herself in the first place, she ASSAULTED the officer. She may not have punched but she interfered with his arrest and she shoved him. Punching may have been extreme but at the same time he was in the right to react. 

Shnookums --- 15 years ago -

Call me crazy, but I didn't see the big deal of Booms video with the girl getting punched. She should not have got in the middle of the officer and the lady he was trying to arrest. Um....ok....maybe not punched, but she should have expected him to come back at her with some sort of force! Clearly he is a crappy cop who lost control of the situation. I think those girls could have beat him up he seemed so whimpy.

In MN video.....if the police had been OFF the job ok....but they were ON the job so I feel they received the correct punishment. I didn't mind the picture taking so much, the girl put herself out there. The lifting of the skirt and touching is what I feel is wrong! 

Noel --- 15 years ago -

I didn't mind the picture taking so much, the girl put herself out there.


This is what I was trying to address when I said "Even if she was flirtatious and coming on to them because she made the choice of her own free will to drink that much, -they- knew she was drunk, and they knew there was a chance it was taking advantage. "

She put herself out there, yes. But she may not have known what she was doing.

Small side-story, a girl I know once drank a bottle of Dimetapp, the grape-flavored cough syrup. In the ambulance to the hospital, she sang sexually explicit things to the people around her, and, to my knowledge, she has no memory of doing this.

She chose to drink the bottle, yes, but if any of them had taken her up on her advances, in my opinion, it would have been a form of rape.

To me, this topic is approaching victim blaming in a scary way. If you're BOTH drunk and do something stupid, that's different, but someone who is entirely sober capitalizing on a drunk woman's (or man's) lowered inhibitions and potential inability to rationalize is wrong, it approaches sexual abuse.

It's the same flawed, dangerous mentality that says if a woman dresses in showy, barely-there clothing, she's asking for male harassment and it's partly her fault if someone gropes her.


Edited to add: I DID see that you agreed the touching and skirt lifting was wrong, I was just responding to the basic "she put herself out there" sentiment, not your post in particular. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground