Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

This is CRAZY!!!!!!!!

who's talking here?

Vicky 1
Vanishing Act 1
MAMMAKITTYKAT 2
Daisey_may 1
IED 1
MorganRose 1
GroomingMyWay 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Vicky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Westboro Church Protected by Free Speech

The case presented the justices with a high-profile question about the breadth of First Amendment speech and assembly protections. A majority of justices ruled that these fundamental rights outweigh the concerns of grieving family members who would rather not deal with the obnoxious protesters from the Kansas church.

In doing so, the judges upheld a lower-court decision to invalidate a $5 million judgment in favor of the father of a dead Marine whose funeral was targeted by the protesters.

In its opinion, the Supreme Court wrote that the United States protects "even hurtful speech" on public issues so that "public debate is not stifled." It ruled that the First Amendment shields the church from being held liable for picketing.

"The 'content' of Westboro's signs plainly relates to public, rather than private, matters," they wrote. "Even if a few of the signs were viewed as containing messages related to a particular individual, that would not change the fact that the dominant theme of Westboro's demonstration spoke to broader public issues.

"Westboro may have chosen the picket location to increase publicity for its views, and its speech may have been particularly hurtful to (the father). That does not mean that its speech should be afforded less than full First Amendment protection under the circumstances of this case," they wrote.

Justice Samuel Alito was the only one to dissent, writing that the church protests simply go too far.

"Our profound national commitment to free and open debate is not a license for the vicious verbal assault that occurred in this case," Alito wrote. "In order to have a society in which public issues can be openly and vigorously debated, it is not necessary to allow the brutalization of innocent victims like petitioner. I therefore respectfully dissent."

For years, the Westboro protesters have popped up at places across the country to voice their displeasure with government policies they think promote homosexuality. They did so in 2006 at the funeral for Matthew Snyder, a Marine killed in Iraq. He was not gay and had no connection to the Westboro cause, but the funeral provided the protesters an opportunity to speak out against government policies.

Father Albert Snyder certainly didn't want anything do with the picketers when he buried his son. "I want them to stop doing this to our military men and women," Snyder told Fox News in October before the arguments. "I want the judges to hear that this case is not about free speech, it's about targeted harassment."

In the days leading up to the funeral, Westboro parishioners, including leader Fred Phelps, notified local authorities of their intention to picket the service. They were kept 1,000 feet away from the church and because of the use of an alternative entrance for church-goers there was no disruption to the memorial. Seven protesters held numerous signs including some that read, "Thank God for Dead Soldiers;" "God Hates Fags;" and "You're Going to Hell." There were no arrests.

Snyder filed a lawsuit against Phelps based on the protest and a subsequent post on the Westboro website about his son Matthew.

A jury awarded Snyder nearly $11 million in damages for the intentional infliction of emotional distress and invasion of privacy. That award was later cut in half and then the Fourth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals set aside the decision in its entirety, ruling that the protests were absolutely protected by the First Amendment.

That decision was upheld by the Supreme Court.

A group of 21 news organizations joined a brief defending Westboro's case. While calling their views "inexplicable and hateful," they expressed concern that a ruling against the church would chill the activities of anyone who wants to speak out on a controversial issue and "threatens to expand dramatically the risk of liability for news media coverage and commentary."

One of the media groups that joined the brief is Dow Jones whose parent company also owns Fox News. 

MorganRose --- 15 years ago -

I think it's discusting they feel the need to do this, and sad there's nothing to stop them. Makes me sick. 

MAMMAKITTYKAT --- 15 years ago -

I agree MorganRose. I get so angry when I hear about them. My uncle has actually riden with some of the freedom riders to help block out their chants during a funeral back home when the son of one of his employees died in Iraq two years ago. They just make me sick. And they are poor excuses for human beings. 

Daisey_may --- 15 years ago -

I don't know why even with free speech this is allowed to go on. People can not be discriminated for race or sex, saying things that are racial or sexual can bring about legal actions and these are not protected by free speech. There is no one other than the Westboro church goers who believe that this crosses a line and is above and beyond obnoxious.

What they are doing should not be protected by the first amendment. Someone should just make a decision and penalize the church and the disgusting decisions they are making. It should not be tolerated like it is. 

Vanishing Act --- 15 years ago -

Well I certainly hope they never go near a funeral of anyone I personally know of any of my friends personally know that I would be at.. I would seriously spit on them and have a few of my own freedom of speech words with them. gah.. This infuriates me that they can get away with this! These are extremists and extremists of all kinds rub me the wrong way! 

GroomingMyWay --- 15 years ago -

i went to the protest they had outside of camp Johnson a few years back even with laryngitis i still managed to cuss them for everything they were worth.the police let us get within 5feet of them one at a time and walk infront of them ..at one point they bundled up the flag and used it for a soccer ball a man from our side picked it up..i was so mad that day but proud i stood my ground for my husband... 

IED --- 15 years ago -

It's sad, but just because it is a bad thing doesn't mean it is, or should be, illegal.
You put enough dings in the armor on the 1st Amendment and it is bound to crumble. It may sound terrible, but their right to free speech is more important than hurt feelings on the matter. 

MAMMAKITTYKAT --- 15 years ago -

I will have to find the link but there are an article about a protest that they had in McAllister oklahoma that was kinda funny. They had just finished a protest and went back to their van to find that someone had slashed their tires. Well when they went to get the tires fixed all of the repair stations in town refused to help them. They were forced to call AAA and have their car towed to the nearest walmart to have their car fixed. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground