Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Can you believe this?

who's talking here?

Vicky 1
Little Miss Knowitall 5
LelaBelle 8
Ja Ja Jacky 2
VanishingAct 4
DMB31 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

LelaBelle --- 15 years ago -

From Extreme Home Makeover Edition to Medical Child Abuse...

Craziness!

Ty Pennington and the philanthropic crew of ABC's "Extreme Makeover: Home Edition" have been giving families the houses of their dreams through sweeping seven-day renovations and reconstructions since the series premiered in 2004. The uplifting reality show brokers in hardest-luck cases that sometimes appear too sad to be true. And in some cases, as it turns out, they are: according to a recent trial in Oregon, it seems the would-be do-gooders were duped by a family falsely claiming two very sick young daughters.

"Extreme Makeover" recipients Chuck and Terri Cerda are the parents of Molly and Maggie, 10 and 8 respectively. Terri, in her appeal to the show, said she suffers from combined immunodeficiency disease, as do her daughters, who had to wear masks to guard against the toxins coursing through the air of their rundown, mold-filled Las Vegas house. You can watch a video of Terri and the two girls posted by the Immune Deficiency Foundation above.

That was before "Extreme Makeover" transformed their abode in March 2009 into "an opulent new home that included high-quality air filtration systems, an elevator, solar-heated swimming pool, gourmet kitchen and floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace," as The Oregonian's Steve Mays writes. But it turned out the Cerdas "couldn't afford the increased cost of operating the larger home. By fall 2009, the house was for sale and the family moved to Oregon."

Which is when their real troubles began. Mays reports:

Several doctors and a hospital social worker began to question Terri Cerda's insistence that her daughters had chronic health problems when tests and examinations indicated otherwise. In January, Dr. Thomas Valvano, an OHSU Doernbecher Children's Hospital pediatrician who specializes in suspected child abuse and neglect, reported the Cerdas to state child-welfare authorities, and in February, the state took temporary custody of the two girls.

The ensuing case in Clackamas County Circuit Court told a story much different from the one presented on television.

Six doctors testified that Molly, 10, and Maggie, 8, did not live in constant medical peril, as Terri Cerda claimed.

Valvano went further. The Cerda children, he told the judge, were victims of medical child abuse.


Link... 

LelaBelle --- 15 years ago -

Here's More:

The world met the Cerda family two years ago when the ABC reality show "Extreme Makeover: Home Edition" showcased their story -- a generous, but struggling Las Vegas couple raising two daughters with serious immune disorders.

The girls, Molly and Maggie, wore face masks to guard against toxins and germs that might be harmless to healthy kids. The TV program paid to demolish the family's mold-filled house and replace it with an opulent new home that included high-quality air filtration systems, an elevator, solar-heated swimming pool, gourmet kitchen and floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace.

Chuck and Terri Cerda beamed as they viewed the haven, but their joy didn't last long.

They said they couldn't afford the increased cost of operating the larger home. By fall 2009, the house was for sale and the family moved to Oregon, where the parents that television producers found so compelling came under scrutiny.

Several doctors and a hospital social worker began to question Terri Cerda's insistence that her daughters had chronic health problems when tests and examinations indicated otherwise. In January, Dr. Thomas Valvano, an OHSU Doernbecher Children's Hospital pediatrician who specializes in suspected child abuse and neglect, reported the Cerdas to state child-welfare authorities, and in February, the state took temporary custody of the two girls.

The ensuing case in Clackamas County Circuit Court told a story much different from the one presented on television.

Six doctors testified that Molly, 10, and Maggie, 8, did not live in constant medical peril, as Terri Cerda claimed.

Valvano went further. The Cerda children, he told the judge, were victims of medical child abuse.

A confrontation

Dr. Sapna Parker, a Sherwood pediatrician, testified about a confrontation after Terri Cerda brought Molly to an emergency room, worried that the girl's coughing, lack of breathing and screaming could be fatal.

A follow-up visit grew heated when Parker explained that if Molly could scream, she was breathing and would be fine. That was the last time Parker saw the Cerdas.

Parker suspected the girls were not as sick as their mother claimed. She called the Oregon Department of Human Services to ask whether there was anything about the family the state felt she should know.

"The story always came from their mother, and it seemed unusual to me that they were not appearing ill," Parker said.

Other doctors testified that they began to believe Terri Cerda isolated her children from other kids, telling them the common cold could be a death sentence. They concluded that she subjected the girls to unneeded medicine and tests, and instilled unwarranted fears that could cause emotional and psychological harm, the doctors said.

The girls were then placed with their maternal grandfather, Jerry McMahan, who temporarily moved from Colorado to Lake Oswego to care for them. McMahan said that during their stay and during his previous visits to the Cerda home over the years, he never saw signs of chronic illness.

They would complain of pain "when it served their purpose," said McMahan, a retired CPA and an ordained minister. Maggie would ask to be carried because her legs hurt. But "when she saw something she wanted to do," he said, "she'd run off and do it."

Home hospital

Terri Cerda, 51, devoted years seeking treatment for her daughters, conferring with a Las Vegas pediatrician and assembling what she described in court as a first-class medical team at the UCLA Ronald Reagan Medical Center in Los Angeles.

In a YouTube video for the Immune Deficiency Foundation posted in May 2009, Cerda says she and her daughters have "combined immune deficiency disease" and talks about the family's home life. "Our house is a veritable hospital," she says. "We have IV poles; we have immunoglobin; we have breathing machines; we have oxygen tanks."

On camera, Cerda describes providing for the extensive medical needs of her children. "The kids get sick," she says, "and you always wonder if that's the last time."

The girls sometimes wore surgical masks on outings and -- on rare occasions -- used a wheelchair when a lot of walking was required, such as visits to the zoo or museums.

But the doctors, drugs and treatments came at a steep price. In 2008, before "Extreme Makeover," the Cerdas filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. They listed assets of $56,789 -- mainly cars, cash and guns -- and debts of more than $233,000, almost half of them unpaid medical bills.

When the Cerdas moved to the Portland-area, they tried to form a new team of medical experts. Terri Cerda took the girls to rheumatologists, pediatricians, pulmonologists and other specialists.

Lab tests revealed some deficiencies or inconclusive results but no serious illnesses.

At a custody hearing in late March, several doctors told Clackamas County Circuit Judge Susie L. Norby that Cerda appeared to be a mother who latched on to a diagnosis and dismissed those who disagreed with her. The doctors said they were unaware of any conclusive diagnosis of severe immune deficiency. One testified that the girls were so boisterous "it was difficult to carry on a conversation."

Cerda testified that her daughters have been in and out of hospitals and clinics most of their lives, sometimes going together for treatment.

The most powerful statement came from Valvano, the child abuse and neglect expert. He reviewed records the state used to make its case and served as an expert witness.

His opinion that the girls were victims of medical child abuse rested on three points: Terri Cerda's pattern of describing symptoms that did not appear to have any medical basis; her history of providing incomplete or inaccurate medical information; and the way she jumped from doctor to doctor, switching when a physician challenged her assertion that the girls were chronically ill, Valvano said.

Experts say such behavior is sometimes also described as Munchausen by proxy syndrome, named for an 18th century German baron prone to exaggeration.

"Claims of immune deficiency arise a lot in Munchausen by proxy cases along with other ailments that are difficult to diagnose," said Dr. Marc D. Feldman, a clinical professor of psychiatry at the University of Alabama, author of "Playing Sick? Untangling the Web of Munchausen Syndrome, Munchausen by Proxy, Malingering, and Factitious Disorder."

Feldman was not involved in the Cerda case and spoke about the syndrome in general.

Medical witnesses for the state said an OHSU social worker talked to Terri Cerda about the possibility that she might be a Munchausen by proxy mom and that Terri Cerda mentioned the social worker's concern to two Portland doctors.

In an interview after the custody case, Terri Cerda acknowledged that Munchausen's by proxy has come up in her visits with health professionals.

She said misunderstanding between parents and professionals can result in good parents being tarred with the label, especially when children suffer from an affliction that comes and goes, leaving them in apparent good health one day and dangerously ill the next.

And some psychiatrists and psychologists agree. They say that doctors and child welfare workers are sometimes too quick to judge.

The defense

When Terri Cerda took the witness stand, she told the court that the girls have a long, documented history of fevers, infections, respiratory and gastrointestinal problems -- all consistent with immune deficiency, she said, and evidence that she wasn't exaggerating their condition.

However, no doctors testified on behalf of the Cerdas.

"We have several hundred pages of medical documents that prove our kids have been diagnosed with immune deficiency disease since they were four years old," Terri Cerda insisted after the court hearing. "We saw doctors that were top notch in the world. The kids have been tested, and you can't lie about lab work."

Asked why those records weren't presented in court, she offered several responses: The medical notes are illegible and hard to interpret. The terminology is complicated. The court refused to admit some defense evidence.

Asked to submit them to The Oregonian for review, Terri Cerda released more than a dozen pages of letters, treatment recommendations and lab analyses. "As you can see, these docs are all stamped as 'exhibits,'" she wrote in an note accompanying the documents. "However, we were not permitted to enter them as evidence."

In a letter dated June 6, 2007, a pediatrician with the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, wrote: "Both children as well as their mother have Primary Immune Deficiency Disease. This disorder leaves them unable to mount a normal response to antigens and causes infections that are difficult to clear. Primary Immune Deficiency Disease is considered a life threatening medical condition."

The pediatrician reiterated his diagnosis in an April 14, 2008, letter documenting his prescription for a medical grade air filtration system: "Both of the Cerda children have Primary Immune Deficiency Disease," he wrote. "The children are homebound as a result of their disorder."

Another physician, the medical director of the laboratory at Arkansas Children's Hospital in Little Rock, reviewed 2010 test results on both children. "Maggie and Molly Cerda have evidence supporting "Specific Polysaccharide Antibody Deficiency," the director wrote. "Both may be at risk of autoimmune disorders."

The Cerdas' attorney, Mikel Miller, insisted that the couple did not mislead doctors and provided authorities with whatever medical records they had.

"They were trying to provide the best care they can," Miller said. "They're the ones with the most to lose. If a child is yelling, 'I'm dying,' it's hard not to respond to that."

'Obsessive'

Judge Norby found Terri Cerda unconvincing.

She sought treatment against doctors' advice and repeatedly exposed her children to unnecessary intervention, Norby found. She called her behavior "obsessive and unjustifiable."

Chuck Cerda, on the other hand, trusted his wife to make appropriate medical decisions and acted reasonably, Norby said. She found the father, a Department of Homeland Security officer, to be a capable parent who was able to take charge of the children's medical needs.

That meant the girls could go home to both parents.

Within days of regaining custody of Maggie and Molly, Terri Cerda left Oregon and resumed treatment with the children's UCLA and Las Vegas doctors, child welfare workers in Oregon learned. The agency went back to the Clackamas County courthouse, arguing that Chuck Cerda did not believe his daughters were at risk from unnecessary medical intervention.

Clackamas County Circuit Judge Douglas K. Van Dyk denied the state's request to take the children back. On April 4, child-protection workers tried again, and again Van Dyk denied the motion.

Van Dyk allowed state authorities to send medical records to the children's doctors in Los Angeles and Las Vegas, and the Oregon Department of Human Services will notify Nevada's child welfare agency about the case.

Terri Cerda did not attend the most recent hearing.

She and the girls moved back to Las Vegas, said Chuck Cerda. He wants to transfer back there, too.

Life in Oregon was like a bad dream, he said, referring to the family's run-ins with child welfare workers. "My girls are having nightmares. They think they're going to be kidnapped again."

Reporter Natalie Feulner of The Oregonian contributed.

-- Steve Mayes


Link 

LelaBelle --- 15 years ago -

Same link as above, right side of page:

Munchhausen by proxy syndrome

What is it? A fancy name for a parent or caregiver who invents or exaggerates medical symptoms to gain attention or sympathy.

How common is it? Gene Evans, Oregon department of Human Services spokesman, said his office sees "very few suspected incidents, maybe one every couple of years."
Does Terri Cerda have the syndrome? That's a matter of opinion. Portland-area pediatricians and social workers concluded she might, but there is no definite standard for diagnosis. Terri Cerda says that both she and her children have immune deficiency disease and that misunderstandings arise because her children can be well one day and deathly ill the next.
Red flags:
* A caregiver who seems medically knowledgeable, deeply interested in medical details or appears to enjoy the hospital setting
* Children with multiple medical problems that don't respond to treatment or seem to be atypical
* A sick child who improves when the caregiver isn't around
 

LelaBelle --- 15 years ago -

What do you guys think? Sick children or Crazy Mom? 

Vicky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

Crazy Mom. 

VanishingAct --- 15 years ago -

It's hard to really know.. Children can be really sick and then out in public because of the excitement of toys or new people they aren't obviously sick. Then there are parents who use their children for attention..

I am certainly glad that I am not a doctor, judge or social worker that my opinions can make or break this family situation and risk doing harm to the children by leaving them or taking them.

They will all be in my prayers. Children, parents and the people that have to make the decisions that it all works out for what is best for the children. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 15 years ago -

Going on a tangent, I think the producers or whoever decides on what families get help, need to do a better job of vetting the families OR scale back on the grandois homes they build for these families.

There have been several families who have received McMansions from the show who are having a hard time meeting the property tax payments on these homes.

I can see building a reasonably sized home with the necessary items the family needs, but it ridiculous what goes into these homes that are totally unnecessary and are not in conformity with the rest of the neighborhood.

This in turn, makes the home a white elephant and harder to sell if/when the need arises. 

DMB31 --- 15 years ago -

I don't think that mom is completely wrong here. Mom's have an instinct with their kids so she knows that something just isnt quite right. She may be exaggerating a little but it's hard not to. She's got one doctor telling her her kids are going to die if she catches a cold and another doctor telling her they are completely fine. I would stay on the safe side too. I would never want to look back and think, my child would be alive if I had just went and gotten that one test done. 

DMB31 --- 15 years ago -

Going on a tangent, I think the producers or whoever decides on what families get help, need to do a better job of vetting the families OR scale back on the grandois homes they build for these families.

There have been several families who have received McMansions from the show who are having a hard time meeting the property tax payments on these homes.

I can see building a reasonably sized home with the necessary items the family needs, but it ridiculous what goes into these homes that are totally unnecessary and are not in conformity with the rest of the neighborhood.

This in turn, makes the home a white elephant and harder to sell if/when the need arises.


Totally agree...this family is defintely not the only one who could not afford the upkeep on the house. Seriously, who needs an elevator in their house? This is not MTV Cribs. 

VanishingAct --- 15 years ago -

by the way.. I know from personal experience that doctors can tell you absolutely nothing is wrong with your child and then it blow up in your face because they were wrong and you trusted them.. 

VanishingAct --- 15 years ago -

Yeah.. do they not realize what kind of bind they put the family into? If they can't afford the upkeep of their old houses how are they going to afford the taxes of an extravagant house like the ones they build?! It's crazy!

I think the hgtv dream homes they do annually has the same issue.. I would LOVE to live in one of those homes.. sooo pretty! Wouldn't be able to keep the home if I won it though because the property taxes would be crazy expensive! 

VanishingAct --- 15 years ago -

Have you seen the types of houses they build?! Aren't taxes based on the VALUE of the current home.. not what their old home taxes were. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 15 years ago -

Have you seen the types of houses they build?! Aren't taxes based on the VALUE of the current home.. not what their old home taxes were.


Yes, the value of the new home. When you're living in a 20 yr old, 1500 sq ft home and then get a brand new, energy efficient, all the bells and whistles, 4000sq ft home, your tax value goes up expotentially.

If the family couldn't afford to do regular, routine maintenance, they certainly can't afford the regular, routine maintenance on a house 3 times the size. 

LelaBelle --- 15 years ago -

I do think the houses should be smaller. A standard two story will do in most cases... and would leave them with more money to build more houses to help more people. By all means, do what the family needs... note, I said NEEDS... but buying the kids their own private circus or whatever is a little over the top.

I think the situation is shady.... and that people are going to have to jump through hoops to get on this show now that there is all this bull crap surrounding it. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

1.It wouldn't be "Extreme Makeover" if it wasn't a standard house

2. I wouldn't watch the show if it was all lame a$$ boring 2 story cookie cutters. Neither would anyone else.

3. They don't do it to help people. They do it for the money, the ratings, the sponsors.

4. Paying tax and extra electric on a house that you don't have to pay any rent or mortgage for... isn't expensive at all. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 15 years ago -

The point is, these people couldn't afford the upkeep on a normal home.

Either because of medical bills or whatever.

Many of these families end up taking a mortgage out to get some cash out of the equity and end up in bigger trouble than what they started with.

A paid off home is like a giant piggy bank just sitting there waiting to be cracked open.

LOTS of people made the mistake of taking the equity out of their homes when the real estate market was hot and their home values were artificially inflated.

Today, their homes aren't valued at what they were, when the equity was taken and no owe more than what their homes are worth.

It's a double edged sword where the blame lies - the homeowners for draining their equity out of their homes and the banks for writing the loans for more than they should have. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 15 years ago -

There were 6 families, as of 2010 who were facing foreclosure because they couldn't afford the higher property taxes, maintenance bills and utilities.

Source 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

The point is, these people couldn't afford the upkeep on a normal home.


These people were paying their mortgages on time, as well as their utilities. Now they have no mortgage and increased utilities. It's all balanced out.

One of the requirements for being a candidate for this show is that you can't be behind on your mortgage. So these people WERE maintaining just fine. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 15 years ago -

Seems IRS needs to get paid for the value of the improvements to the home:

The IRS will treat any prize that you win on one of these shows as income and will force you to pay substantially increased taxes. Not only will the IRS treat your reality show winnings as income you may also be forced to pay higher property taxes. These increased tax payments along with increased costs to operate the new house is what ultimately ruins many of these families that you see on television. 

LelaBelle --- 15 years ago -

Craziness...

Did you see on one of the links that I posted (I think the first one) that this isn't the first scandal that the show has seen and that a bunch of orphans are suing a couple because they adopted the children so that they could go on the show and then returned the children to the orphanage one by one and kept the house? That is... really really awful. More so than the average fraudulent person because they got those children's hopes up about getting a home and a family, then was just like "Oh, sorry... never mind." How awful would that be? To be given your very best dreams then to have them cruelly taken away.. 

LelaBelle --- 15 years ago -

Hmmm...well I guess that answers my question. Oh well! 

LelaBelle --- 15 years ago -

Oh I thought you meant the currrent case. That sucks for the orphans!

Poor kids.. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground