Cherry Point Underground
heart and soul of our Cherry Point community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Cherry Point Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore houses for rent near Cherry Point courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Cash incentive?

who's talking here?

~*MarLa Singer*~ 1
Little Miss Knowitall 4
Noted 4
Mrs Z 3
Nikita 1
MrsSmitty10 4
Ja Ja Jacky 10
Life is Great 5
BlahBlahBlah 1
anonymous 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

POLL: Cash incentive?

How do you feel about cash incentives for honor roll or straight A's?

For it Vote
 
 82.4% (14)
Against it Vote
 
 5.9% (1)
Depends Vote
 
 11.8% (2)
Other Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Noted --- 16 years ago -

How do you feel about cash incentives for honor roll or straight A's? 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

My kids work hard and they deserve a reward. Emily gets straight A's every report card since.... always. Joseph gets all A's with a few B's now and again. He deserves it too. 

~*MarLa Singer*~ --- 16 years ago -

How about the "foot in your a$$ incentive?" That's what my kid will get if she brings me home bad grades!.....

J/K People! 

Mrs Z --- 16 years ago -

My parents and grandparents did it for me, but only during elementary school. Once I got up to intermediate school all bets were off. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Oh, and my two little ones... get donuts.

No, literally. We go out for donuts. Their grades are "Mastered" or "Not mastered".

Um... yeah. So we go out for donuts. 

Life is Great --- 16 years ago -

Once I got up to intermediate school all bets were off.

Same with mine. When I got to high school it was, "if you care about your future you'll work to get good grades regardless of whether or not you get rewarded for them." 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Once I got up to intermediate school all bets were off.


Really? I think that is when you should really be pushing them and rewarding their hard work. I plan to reward big in the upper grades. 

Mrs Z --- 16 years ago -

Eh I'm not a parent so I don't know... that's just what they did for me.

Adding... the older they get I believe they should want to work harder for themselves, not for $$ 

Life is Great --- 16 years ago -

Really? I think that is when you should really be pushing them and rewarding their hard work. I plan to reward big in the upper grades.

Define "reward big". I don't see how you can reward a teenager unless it's with a car. Honestly. 

Noted --- 16 years ago -

Well, okay. Here's a question. My oldest son brought home 4 A's and 2 F's. F'S. So, they have to actually make honor roll if they want to get the reward? Or do you reward per grade? 

Mrs Z --- 16 years ago -

I got $10 for each A and $5 for each B. If I had anything less I wouldn't get anything. Personally, I wouldn't give crap if there are F's no matter how many A's there are with it. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Well, okay. Here's a question. My oldest son brought home 4 A's and 2 F's. F'S. So, they have to actually make honor roll if they want to get the reward? Or do you reward per grade?



F's? Um, no rewards. You have to work hard. Period. That means... busting your butt. An F doesn't come from working hard. If a kid struggles... I could see them getting a C or something. But an F? Nope. In my book, you've just lost your cell, your neighborhood roaming privileges and your TV privileges. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Define "reward big". I don't see how you can reward a teenager unless it's with a car. Honestly.


Ooooooooookay. Well. I honestly don't know what to say to that. My kids are pretty grateful. I don't have to spend $20,000 to reward them.

And neither does my mother... who has a 14 yr old. SHe gets rewards for A's and B's. It usually consists of a RUE 21 shopping trip instead of cash... but whatever.

I plan to use cash, just as I do now. Put pay much bigger than I do now. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

I got $10 for each A and $5 for each B.



That is what I do. 

Life is Great --- 16 years ago -

It usually consists of a RUE 21 shopping trip instead of cash... but whatever.

I plan to use cash, just as I do now. Put pay much bigger than I do now.


That's a good idea! I didn't get rewarded in high school so I wondered about that. Just in case I ever have a kid I'll have ideas!

And my parents would've whooped my butt if I brought home F's. I only got rewarded for honor roll. Anything below a B meant I forfeited my entire reward. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Anything below a B meant I forfeited my entire reward.


That is what I will do too. I haven't had to deal with anything less than a B yet, but my oldest is only 10. But yeah, if you don't bust your butt, you lose the whole thing, IMO.



We don't really focus on the reward all quarter... and we won't when high school hits either. But much like in real life, hard work will come with a bonus in my house. 

Nikita --- 16 years ago -

i got paid by the letter. A)20.00 B)10.00 C)5.00 D) -5 F)grounded until the next progress report and no money period even if i did get an A. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

Here's a question. My oldest son brought home 4 A's and 2 F's. F'S

2 F's? His reward would be grounded until progress reports, concentrating on the 2 failing subjects. Which would include no computer time, no video games, no cell phone and no outside with friends.

Once progress reports came, if there wasn't a DRAMATIC improvement, no privileges would be restored until report cards.

There is no reason for the F's if he got 4 A's.

Obviously he's capable of A's.

If you had no idea this was coming, then there is a bigger issue. 

Noted --- 16 years ago -

No, I wasn't asking if he should get a reward- I obviously know that. I KNOW what the problem is.

I was using that as an example to ask if you go by honor in general or by the letter grade. 

Life is Great --- 16 years ago -

I cried when I got my first D. :( 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

I go by overall report card and the ability of my kid vs. the course load.

Oldest is now in HS and takes AP/Honors classes.

The classes are more challenging/hard compared to regular classes. Under no circumstances will I accept anything below a C on his report card.

4 As and 2Fs = no reward - cash or otherwise. 

Noted --- 16 years ago -

What if it's all A's and one C. What then? 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

If I know he's capable of better than C, no reward. If I know he put in great effort and C was the best he could do, then C is okay.

Anything below a C,then the child either needs extra help, isn't applying themselves or doesn't belong in the class(in high school especially).

Every child is different and I feel, as a parent, I need to recognize their strength and weaknesses. 

anonymous --- 16 years ago -

Bs are the minimum! Abything below that gets punishment, not cash. 

Life is Great --- 16 years ago -

What if it's all A's and one C. What then?

By grade.

You know your child and you know what he/she is capable of. If you know that your child busted his/her butt to earn that C then give them credit for their hard work. If you know they earned that C because they were slacking then don't reward them. 

MrsSmitty10 --- 16 years ago -

I am not a parent but my husband and I have discussed this and agree we will never pay our kids for doing what they are supposed to. I have been on the honor roll, presidents list, deans list, graduated in the top ten in my class. not once have I ever received money for my good grades. But I don't care because pride is more powerful then money.

my SIL had awful awful grades and never got money to bring her grades up, and she is doing great now. So, I know grades can be improved without bribing them to do a better job or keep up the good job.

call us mean but if our kids get what they need to live comfortably then I don't see why we would need to pay them for grades. I'm glad my husband and I agree on this issue too. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

I sort of get what you are saying Mrs Smitty... But.

It's not a bribe. We don't all quarter long say "better keep them grades up if you want $20". We reward them... or give them a bonus for doing their best and working hard.

I 100% believe in punishment. But I also believe in rewards. I'm not just going to punish them every time they do something wrong and not reward them for their hard work.

Like I said, to me it is like a bonus for working hard. In real life, my husband gets a quarterly bonus. Annnnnnnnnnnd so do my kids.

Also... my kids get everything they need and more. My son puts every bit of money he gets away towards his first car. He has saved a ton of money. Our rule for cars is we match you dollar for dollar. So, he'll have a pretty penny saved.

The girls aren't quite as good at saving. They save maybe half what they get in allowance and rewards. Again, for the same thing. 

Little Miss Knowitall --- 16 years ago -

School is their JOB. They should be paid for a job well done.

If grades are poor, apparently, they "took some days off", and their "pay" is docked accordingly/ 

MrsSmitty10 --- 16 years ago -

I 100% believe in punishment. But I also believe in rewards. I'm not just going to punish them every time they do something wrong and not reward them for their hard work.

I completely agree with this statement. I just feel that there are other options to reward them instead of giving them money. I'll leave at that. 

Ja Ja Jacky (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

I also believe that giving your kids their own money helps teach them to be responsible with it. They earn it, they budget it, they spend it wisely... hopefully. For some kids, it takes a little guidance at first, but as they get older, they start catching on and learn to spend their money wisely.

When my kids grow up, I want them to be as smart with their money/credit as I am/was. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Cherry Point Underground